A Legal Ruling Alters Access to Vast Mojave Desert Lands
A recent court decision has led to the closure of over 2,200 miles of off-highway vehicle (OHV) trails in the Mojave Desert. The move, ordered by a federal judge, aims to protect the habitat of the desert tortoise, a species considered vulnerable. This action has generated significant discussion, with some seeing it as a necessary step for conservation and others as an overreach that limits public access.
Background: The Desert Tortoise and Its Habitat
The desert tortoise holds importance in the Mojave Desert ecosystem. As a keystone species, its burrowing activities benefit numerous other animals. However, tortoise populations have faced challenges, and areas once known for their density are now being assessed for protection.
The California Fish and Game Commission has formally recognized the Mojave desert tortoise as endangered.
Certain areas, like the Desert Tortoise Research Natural Area near California City, are noted as locations where tortoise populations are showing signs of recovery.
Biologists monitor these areas using methods like camera traps to track tortoise activity and develop protection strategies.
Signs in off-road areas serve as warnings for drivers to watch for tortoises crossing roads.
The Court's Decision and its Scope
A federal judge has mandated the closure of a substantial network of OHV routes. This decision stems from a legal process that identified violations concerning the protection of species habitat.
Read More: Over 90 Avalanche Deaths This Winter Due to Snow and Risky Skiing
The Bureau of Land Management (BLM) has been ordered to close these trails.
The ruling addresses off-road vehicle use in areas identified as critical habitat for the desert tortoise.
One source mentions U.S. District Judge Susan Illston ruled that blocking access to critical habitat was a suitable remedy for the BLM violating federal statutes.
The ruling specifically concerns closures in the western Mojave Desert.
While significant mileage is affected, it is noted that a substantial portion of potential OHV routes and designated "open areas" remain accessible.
Arguments for Closure: Protecting Endangered Species
Proponents of the closure emphasize the need to safeguard the desert tortoise and its environment from the impacts of off-road vehicle use.
Studies cited indicate that closing areas to OHVs is beneficial to the desert tortoise.
Agencies have acknowledged that OHVs can cause negative impacts on protected animals.
The closure is seen as a measure to prevent further harm to a species reliant on its habitat for survival.
The tortoise's burrows are crucial for other desert wildlife.
Concerns Regarding Public Land Access and Due Process
Conversely, some groups express concern that the judicial decision bypasses established processes for land management and potentially sets a precedent for future public land access.
Some characterize the ruling as an instance of a judge imposing land-use policy without congressional action, community input, or accountability.
There is a view that this decision threatens all public land access, not just for OHV users.
Critics argue that such broad decisions made by courts undermine the democratic process and public trust.
The BlueRibbon Coalition frames the situation as courts stepping beyond their role to manage land use without accountability or congressional authority.
An appeal of the closure has been called for, suggesting a desire to challenge the ruling.
Evidence of Impact and Habitat Use
Evidence suggests that off-road vehicles have been observed operating in or near sensitive tortoise habitats.
An observer noted vehicles driving off designated routes, with one appearing to then drive off the established path.
Another observation involved a pickup truck and a utility task vehicle driving on a trail, creating dust, in an area where vulnerable tortoises reside.
The ruling follows a six-year legal battle.
Expert Analysis
"Studies in the administrative record show that closing areas to [off-highway vehicles] is beneficial to the desert tortoise, and the agencies have long recognized that OHVs cause numerous negative impacts on the protected animal."— U.S. District Judge Susan Illston
Conclusion and Implications
The closure of over 2,200 miles of OHV trails in the Mojave Desert represents a significant outcome of a legal dispute focused on protecting the desert tortoise. The decision highlights the ongoing tension between conservation efforts for endangered species and the use of public lands for recreational activities.
The ruling by U.S. District Judge Susan Illston is directly linked to the protection of critical habitat for the desert tortoise.
The closure is a result of the Bureau of Land Management violating federal statutes related to species protection.
While the immediate impact is on OHV users, concerns have been raised about the broader implications for public land access and the role of the judiciary in land management.
The situation underscores the importance of the desert tortoise as a keystone species in the Mojave ecosystem.
The legal battle, spanning six years, led to this judicial intervention aimed at safeguarding a vulnerable reptile.
Sources Used and Context:
Los Angeles Times: "This California reptile closed down a Mojave Desert haven for off-road racing" - Provides context on the desert tortoise as a keystone species, its endangered status, and the judicial order to close trails in its habitat. (https://www.latimes.com/environment/story/2026-02-19/mojave-desert-off-roading-hotspot-shut-down-tortoise-protection)
dnyuz.com: "The Mojave Desert is a hot spot for off-roading. Here’s why a judge shut down more than 2,200 miles of trails" - Reinforces the desert tortoise's ecological role and mentions areas of population recovery. (https://dnyuz.com/2026/02/19/the-mojave-desert-is-a-hot-spot-for-off-roading-heres-why-a-judge-shut-down-more-than-2200-miles-of-trails/)
Motorcycle.com: "Act Now: Appeal Closure of 2,200 Miles of OHV Routes in Mojave Desert" - Frames the decision as a threat to all public land access and criticizes the judicial imposition of land-use policy. (https://www.motorcycle.com/bikes/news/act-now-appeal-closure-of-2200-miles-of-ohv-routes-in-mojave-desert-44661709)
BlueRibbon Coalition: "Rogue Judge Closes 2,200 Miles of OHV Routes in the Mojave Desert" - Expresses strong criticism of the ruling, labeling it an overreach and a threat to democratic processes in land management. (https://blueribboncoalition.org/rogue-judge-closes-2200-miles-of-ohv-routes-in-the-mojave-desert/)
Green Matters: "California’s Mojave Desert Is an Off-Roading Favorite. It's Now Shut Down to Protect a Rare Animal" - Describes the scene of off-roading in the Mojave and mentions specific observations of vehicles in sensitive areas. (https://www.greenmatters.com/pn/californias-mojave-desert-is-an-off-roading-favorite-its-now-shut-down-to-protect-a-rare-animal)
Adventure Rider: "Mojave Off-Road Riding Closure! Sign This Petition" - Reiterates the concern about precedent and the judicial nature of the land-use decision. (https://www.advrider.com/mojave-off-road-riding-closure-sign-this-petition/)
The Victorville Daily Press: "A win for conservationists, a loss for riders. 2,200 miles of Mojave OHV land now closed" - Details the judicial order, the duration of the legal battle, and the justification of protecting critical habitat for species like the desert tortoise. (https://eu.vvdailypress.com/story/news/environment/2026/02/20/mojave-desert-ohv-routes-closed-to-protect-desert-tortoises/88721318007/)
E&E News: "Judge orders off-highway vehicles off some Mojave desert trails" - Provides direct quotes from the judge's opinion, stating the benefits of OHV closures for the desert tortoise and the BLM's violation of statutes. It also notes the remaining accessible areas. (https://www.eenews.net/articles/judge-orders-off-highway-vehicles-off-some-mojave-desert-trails/)
Badlinesgoodtimes.com: "Mojave OHV closures coming" - Primarily a forum post indicating awareness of upcoming closures, with a link to a meeting. Less direct reporting, more community discussion. (https://forum.badlinesgoodtimes.com/threads/mojave-ohv-closures-coming.2916/)
