A U.S. District Court judge has dismissed 10 of 13 claims brought by Blake Lively against actor-director Justin Baldoni regarding the production of the film It Ends With Us. The ruling, delivered by Judge Lewis Liman in the Southern District of New York, effectively strikes down central allegations of sexual harassment, defamation, and conspiracy.
The litigation now proceeds on a significantly narrowed scope. The remaining core of the case centers exclusively on alleged retaliation, breach of contract, and aiding and abetting—charges that pivot away from the personal conduct of Baldoni himself, who is no longer a defendant in the remaining active counts.
| Status | Claim Category |
|---|---|
| Dismissed | Sexual Harassment, Defamation, Conspiracy |
| Active | Retaliation, Breach of Contract, Aiding and Abetting |
Court Findings on "Sexual Context"
The judicial reasoning clarifies that certain contested interactions—specifically those involving the staging of sexual scenes—did not meet the legal threshold for a "hostile work environment." Judge Liman noted that such suggestions, within the creative framework of a film centered on adult themes, fell within reasonable professional expectations. Consequently, the sexual harassment claims were found legally insufficient.
Read More: Todd Blanche becomes Acting Attorney General after Pam Bondi removed April 2
Institutional Conflict and Public Perception
The case has functioned as a conduit for wider industry scrutiny, drawing in high-profile figures including Taylor Swift and Ryan Reynolds. While Lively’s legal counsel, Sigrid McCawley, maintains that the focus remains on a "vicious form of online retaliation" aimed at damaging her client’s reputation, representatives for the defense have characterized the outcome as a necessary correction.
"We're very pleased the Court dismissed all sexual harassment claims and every claim brought against the individual defendants," stated Alexandra Shapiro and Jonathan Bach, counsel for Baldoni.
Contextual Trajectory
The dispute, which has unfolded over more than a year, has been marked by a series of [Retaliation ] and [Defamation ] claims stemming from the filming of It Ends With Us. What began as a broad multi-claim lawsuit involving individual production members has been reduced to a targeted legal skirmish. With a trial date still fixed for May 18, the reduction of the case represents a shift from a wide-reaching inquiry into personal conduct toward a narrower administrative review of post-production interactions and contractual obligations. The "smear campaign" allegations, once secondary, now define the entirety of the upcoming courtroom proceedings.
Read More: Judge Drops Most Blake Lively Lawsuit Claims Against Justin Baldoni in New York
