Brockman: Musk Threatened Him Over OpenAI Control in 2017

OpenAI co-founder Greg Brockman testified that Elon Musk threatened him during a 2017 meeting. Brockman felt he was going to be hit by Musk.

Intense Confrontation Detailed in Court

Greg Brockman, a co-founder of OpenAI, testified Tuesday in a federal court, recounting a 2017 meeting where he felt physically threatened by Elon Musk. Brockman stated that during a negotiation over Musk's desire for a controlling stake in the burgeoning artificial intelligence company, Musk's demeanor shifted abruptly, leading Brockman to believe he "was going to hit me."

The core of the dispute, according to Brockman's testimony, revolved around Musk's demand for a 62.5% majority control of OpenAI. Brockman, alongside fellow founders Sam Altman and Ilya Sutskever, considered removing Musk from the board at the time, but ultimately decided against it. Brockman conveyed that Musk’s proposals for equity stakes in the nascent for-profit entity were rejected by Brockman, who argued that no single individual should hold absolute sway over such powerful technology.

Read More: Vivo X300 Ultra and FE Phones Launch in India Today

'I thought he was going to hit me,' OpenAI co-founder says of Musk - 1

Brockman further elaborated on Musk's stated motivations during the tense exchange, recounting that Musk claimed he "needed $80 billion dollars to create a city" on Mars and that "people needed to know he was in charge." Musk had also reportedly warned that he would cease funding OpenAI if his demands were not met.

Seeds of Disagreement and Departure

The testimony surfaced during the second week of a month-long trial in Oakland, initiated by Musk's lawsuit against OpenAI. Musk's legal action aims to reverse the company's transition to a for-profit model, which he alleges betrays its original nonprofit mission. Brockman's account paints a picture of escalating disagreements over the direction and control of the AI enterprise.

'I thought he was going to hit me,' OpenAI co-founder says of Musk - 2

Musk ultimately left OpenAI in 2018, reportedly to focus on artificial intelligence endeavors at Tesla. OpenAI, however, counters that Musk's departure was voluntary, stemming from his failure to secure majority control, and that he has since become a direct competitor through his own AI venture, xAI.

Read More: Airlines Cancel 13,000 Flights Due to High Fuel Costs

The trial is expected to feature testimony from OpenAI CEO Sam Altman later in the week.

'I thought he was going to hit me,' OpenAI co-founder says of Musk - 3

Background on OpenAI's Evolution

Founded as a nonprofit, OpenAI later introduced a for-profit arm to attract substantial investment needed for its ambitious AI development, notably leading to the creation of ChatGPT. This evolution, particularly the shift to prioritizing the for-profit entity, is central to the legal battle Musk has initiated. Brockman's testimony provides a direct account from a key figure present during the early, pivotal moments of friction within the organization.

Notably, Brockman also mentioned learning through public reports that Musk was the father of twins born to Yesim Zilis, an individual who had previously informed Brockman about her pregnancy. This detail emerged as Brockman discussed how Zilis helped manage Musk's frustrations with OpenAI, even as some board members had wished to remove her from the board.

Read More: EU Plans New Cybersecurity Law to Phase Out Chinese Tech

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What did Greg Brockman say Elon Musk did in a 2017 meeting?
Greg Brockman testified that Elon Musk threatened him physically during a 2017 meeting. Brockman felt Musk was going to hit him.
Q: Why did Elon Musk and OpenAI co-founders argue in 2017?
Elon Musk wanted 62.5% control of OpenAI, but co-founders like Greg Brockman did not agree. Brockman said Musk needed money for a Mars city and wanted people to know he was in charge.
Q: What is the current court case about?
Elon Musk is suing OpenAI to reverse its for-profit model. Musk claims it goes against the original nonprofit mission. Brockman's testimony is part of this trial.
Q: Why did Elon Musk leave OpenAI?
Elon Musk left OpenAI in 2018. OpenAI says he left because he could not get majority control. Musk says he left to focus on AI at Tesla.