US Immigration Numbers and Political Talk

New numbers show more people are coming to the US border. Politicians have different ideas about what this means. We explain the facts simply.
By Newsroom | US Immigration, US Politics |

A Stark Divide on Border Realities

The flow of people entering the United States without authorization has become a central issue in American politics. Data from the Department of Homeland Security indicates a significant increase in encounters at the southern border under the Biden administration. This rise has fueled sharp accusations from some political factions, notably Republicans, who describe the situation as an "invasion" and a deliberate tactic by Democrats to destabilize the nation. Conversely, analyses suggest that the impact of unauthorized immigration on political representation is minimal, and that restrictive border policies have been implemented by the current administration. The political landscape surrounding immigration appears deeply fractured, with contrasting interpretations of the data and motivations of political parties.

INVASION! One Simple Graph Demonstrates How Dems Tried to Destroy America With Illegal Immigration - 1

Background: Shifting Tides and Political Narratives

The debate over immigration in the United States has intensified, with particular focus on the southern border. Recent years have seen significant shifts in apprehension numbers, with former President Donald Trump pointing to a chart of border crossings during his last months in office, stating that apprehensions had "more than quadrupled" from a pandemic low and were higher than when he began his term. Conversely, data shows that apprehensions at the border during Trump’s final two months were higher than during President Barack Obama’s final two months.

Read More: Many ICE Workers Accused of Bad Actions as Agency Grows

INVASION! One Simple Graph Demonstrates How Dems Tried to Destroy America With Illegal Immigration - 2

More recently, under the Biden administration, official data indicates that around 84,000 migrants crossed the southern border unlawfully in June. The Biden administration has enacted sweeping restrictions on asylum at the US-Mexico border, aiming to prevent illegal entry and ease pressure on border posts. Despite these measures, there have been high-profile cases involving migrants charged with serious crimes, which have been amplified in political discourse.

INVASION! One Simple Graph Demonstrates How Dems Tried to Destroy America With Illegal Immigration - 3

Political figures have openly accused opposing parties of using immigration for political gain. Texas Lieutenant Governor Dan Patrick has stated that Democrats are allowing immigrants into the country for political advantage, a claim that has been met with strong opposition from Democratic leaders. These accusations come as bipartisan efforts to reform immigration have faltered, with Republicans indicating that border security legislation is a key condition for supporting other aid packages, such as that for Ukraine.

Read More: Trump's Policies Changed Air Travel

INVASION! One Simple Graph Demonstrates How Dems Tried to Destroy America With Illegal Immigration - 4

Data from the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) shows a marked increase in encounters at the southern border during the Biden administration. This surge in encounters is a key point of contention.

  • Trump Administration: Apprehensions at the southwest border during Trump’s final two months in office were substantially higher than during President Obama’s last two months. Numbers had quadrupled from a pandemic low and exceeded those at the start of Trump's presidency.

  • Biden Administration: Official data shows approximately 84,000 migrant crossings in June. Encounters at the southern border have increased significantly under President Biden. The administration has implemented new restrictions on asylum and border crossings.

Political Framing of Immigration

The narrative surrounding immigration has become a potent political tool, with accusations of deliberate strategies by both parties.

Read More: Airport Security Workers May Not Get Paid If Government Funding Stops

  • Republican Accusations: Some Republicans allege that Democrats are intentionally allowing increased immigration, with claims that this is a plot to sway congressional apportionment and engineer a "silent revolution." These accusations are often amplified by referencing high-profile crimes committed by undocumented immigrants.

  • Democratic Counterarguments: Democratic leaders have refuted these claims, characterizing them as baseless and politically motivated. Studies on the impact of unauthorized immigration on congressional apportionment suggest that this impact is minimal.

  • "Invasion" Rhetoric: The term "invasion" has moved from the fringes to the mainstream of the Republican message on immigration.

The Role of Immigration in Electoral Politics

The political strategies of both major parties regarding immigration and its impact on voter demographics have been subject to analysis.

  • Democratic Strategies: For a considerable period, Democrats believed that a leftward shift on immigration policy would bolster support among Latino voters. However, pre-election polling indicated that this strategy may not have yielded the expected results, with immigration becoming a "liability" rather than a "secret weapon."

  • Republican Strategies: Republicans have focused on border security as a core issue. The HR 2 bill, passed by the House, has become a benchmark for their demands. There is an underlying belief among some Republicans that a future Trump administration would achieve their desired outcomes without legislative compromise.

Apportionment and Unauthorized Immigration

The question of how unauthorized immigrants affect political representation is a point of discussion, though its impact is deemed minimal by some analyses.

Read More: Part of Homeland Security Department Closes Because Lawmakers Can't Agree on Money

  • Impact on Seats: Studies suggest that unauthorized immigration's impact on the apportionment of congressional seats is minor. For example, New York has a substantial number of undocumented immigrants, but its apportionment has not changed significantly in relation to this factor. Similarly, states like Florida, Alabama, and Ohio have seen their representation shift, with analyses indicating that unauthorized immigration is not the sole or primary driver.

Expert Analysis on Political Strategies

  • Brookings Institution: Analysis suggests that bipartisan immigration reform has collapsed, partly due to Republican insistence on border security measures. There is a concern that if a Republican candidate wins the presidency, legislative compromise on immigration might be abandoned in favor of executive action.

  • The Atlantic: Reports indicate that Democrats may have misjudged the political implications of their immigration stances, potentially alienating key voter blocs despite efforts to court them with left-leaning policies.

Conclusion: A Politicized Landscape

The available evidence presents a complex picture of US immigration. Apprehension data indicates significant numbers at the southern border, with trends shifting across different administrations. Politically, immigration has become a highly charged issue, with Republicans employing strong rhetoric and linking it to national security and political strategy, while Democrats face scrutiny over their policy effectiveness and electoral calculations. Claims of a deliberate Democratic plot to use immigration for political gain, such as swaying apportionment, are largely unsubstantiated by analyses that highlight the minimal impact of unauthorized immigrants on seat allocation. The collapse of bipartisan reform efforts further underscores the deep divisions, with each party appearing to prioritize its own strategic objectives over comprehensive solutions. The discourse surrounding "invasion" highlights a stark contrast in how the border situation is perceived and communicated.

Sources Used

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Are more people coming to the US border?
Yes, numbers show more people are being met at the southern border.
Q: What do politicians say about this?
Some politicians say it is a big problem and blame the other party. Others say the impact is not as big as some claim.
Q: Is immigration helping one party get more power?
Some people say this, but studies show it has a small effect on how many seats each party gets in government.
Q: Are there new rules for people wanting to come to the US?
Yes, the current government has made new rules to limit people crossing the border without permission.