Tucson Police Arrest Kayla Noel Day and Luke Anthony Daley in Nancy Guthrie Disappearance Case on February 13

Two people, Kayla Noel Day and Luke Anthony Daley, are now in custody after Nancy Guthrie went missing on February 1. This is a big step in the investigation.
By Newsroom | Crime, Arizona |

The disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, 84, from her Tucson, Arizona, home on February 1, has escalated into a complex investigation marked by public speculation and official updates. As law enforcement probes for leads, two individuals, Kayla Noel Day and Luke Anthony Daley, have been taken into custody. Simultaneously, unverified claims linking family members to the case have emerged and subsequently been addressed by authorities.

Timeline of Key Events

  • February 1: Nancy Guthrie, mother of Savannah Guthrie, was reported missing from her Tucson area residence. Law enforcement stated she was believed to have been taken against her will.

  • February 3: The FBI released images, purportedly from surveillance footage at Ms. Guthrie's property, showing a masked individual on her porch shortly before her disappearance.

  • February 12: A gray Range Rover, reportedly involved in the investigation, was stopped by law enforcement in the Catalina Foothills area. The vehicle was later impounded from a parking lot near a restaurant for forensic processing.

  • February 13: A SWAT team reportedly detained Luke Anthony Daley at a residence connected to the investigation. Social media posts claimed a raid occurred at a neighbor's home, with some posts identifying Kayla Noel Day as arrested during this event.

  • Recent Days: Authorities have publicly confirmed that Kayla Noel Day and Luke Anthony Daley are in custody in connection with the case.

Individuals of Interest and Public Speculation

Kayla Noel Day and Luke Anthony Daley

  • Custody Status: Both Kayla Noel Day and Luke Anthony Daley are currently in custody. Their precise role and charges in relation to Ms. Guthrie's disappearance remain under investigation.

  • Vehicle Connection: A gray Range Rover seized on February 12 has been linked to the investigation. Forensic teams processed this vehicle.

  • Viral Claims: Online speculation has extensively linked Kayla Noel Day and Luke Anthony Daley to the case, including alleged familial connections to Nancy Guthrie and involvement with the seized Range Rover.

Guthrie Family and Familial Connections

  • Allegations: Social media platforms have been a significant source of unverified claims, with some posts alleging a familial connection between Kayla Noel Day and Nancy Guthrie, identifying Day as a purported niece. Further claims suggested Penny Guthrie, purportedly Nancy's sister, was also involved.

  • Official Denials:

  • The Pima County Sheriff's Department, through Sheriff Chris Nanos, has explicitly cleared the Guthrie family of any involvement in Nancy Guthrie's disappearance.

  • Public records do not indicate that Nancy Guthrie has a sister named Penny Guthrie.

  • Law enforcement officials have not confirmed any familial connections between individuals questioned and Nancy Guthrie.

  • It has been stated that there is no proof Kayla Noel Day is Nancy Guthrie's niece.

Evidence and Investigative Actions

  • Surveillance Footage: The FBI released images and video from surveillance cameras at Nancy Guthrie's property. These images depict a masked individual on the porch shortly before her disappearance. Authorities believe this individual is a possible suspect.

  • Vehicle Forensics: A seized gray Range Rover is undergoing forensic examination for potential evidence.

  • Data Recovery: Investigators are working to recover data, including potentially from hard drives that were formatted, with the understanding that data may still be recoverable before it is overwritten. The home reportedly contained multiple cameras, suggesting the possibility of additional video evidence.

  • Information Sharing: The FBI has released new identifying details about the possible suspect seen in the released footage and has increased the reward for information.

Expert Analysis and Official Statements

"Law enforcement officials have not publicly confirmed those allegations." - Timesnownews.com, Article 1, referencing viral claims about Kayla Noel Day and Luke Daley.

"The Guthrie family are victims plain and simple… The members of the Guthrie family have repeatedly been linked on social media as possible suspects in Nancy's kidnapping." - Mashable, Article 6, highlighting the ongoing online narrative versus official findings.

"Sheriff Chris Nanos of the Pima County Sheriff’s Department has publicly cleared the Guthrie family of involvement in Nancy Guthrie’s January 31 disappearance." - ChannelZ NOW, Article 7, confirming official statements exonerating the family.

"As the investigation continues, officials have urged the public to refrain from spreading unverified information while they work to gather evidence and determine Nancy Guthrie’s fate." - Wionews.com, Article 2, emphasizing the official call for responsible information dissemination.

Conclusion and Next Steps

The investigation into Nancy Guthrie's disappearance involves multiple avenues, including the examination of surveillance footage, forensic analysis of a seized vehicle, and the custody of Kayla Noel Day and Luke Anthony Daley. Authorities have taken deliberate steps to counter widespread misinformation, particularly regarding alleged familial involvement of the Guthrie family, which has been officially refuted. The focus remains on gathering concrete evidence to determine Ms. Guthrie's whereabouts and fate, and to establish the precise roles of the individuals in custody.

Read More: Prince Andrew Arrested in UK on February 19, 2026, for Misconduct

  • Key Unknowns: The specific nature of Kayla Noel Day and Luke Anthony Daley's alleged involvement, their relationship (if any) to Nancy Guthrie, and the direct link of the Range Rover to the disappearance are critical details that remain undisclosed pending further investigation.

  • Next Steps: Continued forensic analysis of the Range Rover and other potential evidence, alongside further investigative interviews, are presumed to be ongoing. The FBI's efforts to identify the masked individual in the surveillance footage and the increasing reward for information suggest a sustained focus on identifying key persons of interest.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Who was arrested in connection with Nancy Guthrie's disappearance on February 13?
Kayla Noel Day and Luke Anthony Daley were arrested on February 13 in connection with the disappearance of 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie from her Tucson home.
Q: What is the latest on the investigation into Nancy Guthrie's disappearance?
Police have confirmed Kayla Noel Day and Luke Anthony Daley are in custody. A gray Range Rover was also stopped and processed as part of the investigation.
Q: Are the Guthrie family members involved in Nancy Guthrie's disappearance?
No, the Pima County Sheriff's Department has clearly stated that the Guthrie family is not involved and is also a victim in this case.
Q: What evidence do police have in the Nancy Guthrie case?
Investigators have surveillance footage showing a masked person on Nancy Guthrie's porch before she disappeared. They are also examining a seized gray Range Rover for clues.
Q: What is being done about rumors linking family members to the case?
Authorities have strongly denied any familial connection between those arrested and Nancy Guthrie, and have explicitly cleared the Guthrie family of any involvement to stop the spread of false information.