Local groups in Sydney are currently taking legal and physical action to stop the building of new rugby and housing projects on green spaces. At Fred Caterson Reserve, residents have blocked work and asked a court to stop the project because they believe it will harm local plants and animals. At the same time, in the City of Ryde, the local council is fighting to stop a historic sports field from being turned into a housing estate. These events show a growing disagreement between people who want to protect the environment and those who say Sydney needs more places for sports and housing. The core of the problem is whether the government can find a way to build new facilities without destroying the natural areas that residents value.
Timeline of Events and Key People
The current disputes are part of a long-term discussion about how to use land in Sydney’s suburbs.
Read More: White House East Wing Rubble Moved to DC Golf Course Causing Lawsuit in February 2026
November 2020: The NRL (National Rugby League) pressures the NSW Government to fund suburban sports grounds, threatening to move the Grand Final if money is not provided.
July 2024: Residents near Fred Caterson Reserve voice fears about "plastic grass" (synthetic turf) and its impact on waterways.
August 2024: The City of Ryde council attempts to stop the North Ryde RSL from building 132 townhouses on the TG Millner Fields.
February 2026: Protesters block development at Fred Caterson Reserve. A court injunction is filed to stop work based on environmental concerns.
Key Actors:
Fred Caterson Action Group: A local group led by Susan Sandercock fighting the development.
Mila Kasby: A Hills Shire Councillor who supports the protesters.
Trenton Brown: The Liberal Mayor of Ryde who argues there are not enough sports fields for the community.
Kerrie Sicard: A wildlife rescuer concerned about endangered bushland.
Documented Evidence and Statements
The following information comes from official statements and reports regarding the two main sites under discussion.
| Topic | Evidence / Statement | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Environmental Risk | Claim that the impact on endangered species was not properly checked. | Fred Caterson Action Group |
| Synthetic Turf | Residents fear "plastic grass" will pollute water; Council previously said there were no current plans for it. | SMH Report / Kerrie Sicard |
| Field Shortage | There is a "deficit" (lack) of sports fields in the local community. | Mayor Trenton Brown |
| Housing Proposal | Plans submitted to turn TG Millner Fields into 132 townhouses. | North Ryde RSL / ABC News |
“The development proposal did not balance the impact on the surrounding environment.” — Mila Kasby, Hills Councillor.
The Environmental Dispute at Fred Caterson Reserve
The main reason for the protests at Fred Caterson Reserve is the fear that construction will destroy the homes of rare animals.
Susan Sandercock and the Fred Caterson Action Group argue that the bushland is "endangered."
They claim that the legal process used to approve the site did not look closely enough at the nature living there.
A legal request (injunction) was filed in the Land and Environment Court to stop all work until a judge can review the facts.
A second concern involves the use of synthetic or "plastic" grass. While some officials have stated there are no immediate plans for this material, residents remain worried. They believe synthetic grass can lead to hotter ground temperatures and chemical runoff into local water systems.
The Fight for TG Millner Fields
In a different part of Sydney, the City of Ryde is trying to prevent the North Ryde RSL from turning a historic rugby field into 132 townhouses.
The council wants to keep the land for sports and public use.
Mayor Trenton Brown has stated that the area already lacks enough fields for children and local teams to play on.
NSW Local Government Minister Ron Hoenig suggested the council could try to buy the land if they could find the money, but the owners (North Ryde RSL) have moved forward with their plans for housing.
The Role of Professional Sports Funding
A broader issue affecting these local fights is the relationship between the NRL and the NSW Government. In 2020, the NRL argued that suburban grounds needed more money to stay modern. This created pressure on local councils and the state government to upgrade old parks into "elite" or high-quality training facilities.
Some residents feel these "elite" upgrades are designed for professional athletes rather than the local community.
There is a question: Should public parks be changed to satisfy the needs of professional sports leagues?
Expert Analysis
Environmental Perspectives:Wildlife experts like Kerrie Sicard point out that once bushland is cleared for a sports precinct, it cannot be easily replaced. The loss of trees means local animals have nowhere to go. Investigators have noted that when local governments prioritize sports, the "natural value" of the land is often treated as less important.
Urban Planning Perspectives:Government officials like Ron Hoenig and Trenton Brown focus on the needs of a growing population. If more people move to Sydney, they need places to live (townhouses) and places to play (rugby fields). They view the current shortage of fields as a problem that must be fixed to keep the community healthy.
Summary of Findings
The investigation into these developments shows three main points of conflict:
Nature vs. Growth: Protesters believe the environmental cost of new rugby fields is too high, especially when it involves endangered bushland.
Public vs. Private: There is a dispute over whether land owned by clubs (like the RSL) should be used for private profit (housing) or public benefit (sports).
Local vs. Professional: Many residents feel that local parks are being turned into professional training zones that do not serve the average person.
The next step in this situation depends on the Land and Environment Court. If the court decides that the environmental checks were not done correctly, the project at Fred Caterson Reserve may be forced to change or stop. For TG Millner Fields, the future depends on whether the council can find the money to purchase the land before building begins.
Read More: Plastic Industry Knew Recycling Was Hard for Decades, New Documents Show
Primary Sources
ABC News (2026): Residents turn to blocking Fred Caterson development. Link
Sydney Morning Herald (2024): Why residents want to stop an elite rugby precinct. Link
ABC News (2024): Sydney council takes final stand against plan to develop historic green space. Link
2GB Radio (2020): Suburban grounds caught in the crossfire of NRL’s stoush. Link
