Charlie Curnow's first game for Sydney Swans shows new forward line in practice match on February 20, 2025

Charlie Curnow played his first match simulation for the Sydney Swans on February 20, 2025. This is his first look at the new forward line after his trade from Carlton.
By Newsroom | AFL, Sydney |

Early Look at Swans' New Forward Line in Practice Match

A recent unofficial match simulation between the Western Bulldogs and Sydney Swans offered an early glimpse of the Swans' revamped forward capabilities. Notably, Charlie Curnow, a recent high-profile acquisition, was observed participating. The match, held at the Western Bulldogs' Whitten Oval, served as a tune-up with four 30-minute quarters played without a running clock. The game was accessible via Fox Footy and Kayo Sports. Several key players were absent for both teams; the Swans were without Tom Papley, Justin McInerney, and Chad Warner, while the Bulldogs were missing six Origin players and Adam Treloar. Ryley Sanders was slated to play despite a hamstring concern.

Background of Charlie Curnow's Move to Sydney

The trade of Charlie Curnow from Carlton to the Sydney Swans represents a significant player movement within the AFL. Reports indicate the deal involved substantial draft picks and a young forward from Carlton's side, alongside Curnow's move to Sydney. This transfer has been framed as an effort by the Swans to bolster their forward line and enhance their prospects for a premiership. Curnow's departure from Carlton followed a period where trade rumors persisted. He had previously expressed interest in leaving the Melbourne area.

Read More: Gold Coast Suns and St Kilda Saints pre-season game shows new players but raises contract questions

"Bringing in Curnow at the expense of multiple first-round picks shows conviction." - Article 5

Evidence of Curnow's Impact and Future Considerations

Observations from the match simulation suggest Curnow made a positive impression. One report highlighted his performance as "sublime" during his initial appearance with the Swans in this context. His move to Sydney followed a period of discussion about his future with Carlton, where he had experienced injury setbacks.

Curnow’s ‘sublime’ first glimpse as new ‘Swans Surge’ unleashed on Dogs — AFL LIVE - 1

"Curnow’s long-term deal gives Carlton significant leverage in any trade negotiations, but it has also served to highlight a problem in Cornes’ eyes." - Article 2

The financial and list management implications of the trade were considerable, with Carlton reportedly turning down an offer of three first-round picks from Geelong before agreeing to a deal with Sydney.

Player's Perspective on the Move

Charlie Curnow himself has spoken about his transition. He has mentioned experiencing a "good feeling" about his move to Sydney, likening it to exploring a new city. His statements suggest an eagerness to embrace a new lifestyle and connect with his new teammates.

Read More: Why Sydney residents are fighting new rugby fields and housing projects at Fred Caterson Reserve

"I mean, it was a bit hectic there for the last month, but, yeah, we're pretty pumped to get out there and enjoy the new lifestyle and the new team, get to play with some new group of boys." - Article 4

He also reflected on his time at Carlton and expressed anticipation for playing alongside his new Sydney teammates.

Curnow’s ‘sublime’ first glimpse as new ‘Swans Surge’ unleashed on Dogs — AFL LIVE - 2

Analysis of Trade Dynamics and Player Value

The trade appears to have been a complex negotiation. While Carlton reportedly turned down an initial offer from Geelong, which included three first-round picks, they ultimately agreed to a deal with Sydney that saw Curnow move. Reports suggest the deal involved considerable compensation for Carlton, including draft capital and a young player. Curnow, a two-time Coleman Medallist, is considered a key asset whose best form can significantly impact a team's finals aspirations.

"Charlie Curnow is officially a Swan, with Carlton and Sydney agreeing on one of the largest deals in trade history." - Article 6

The departure of Curnow from Carlton, a club undergoing changes, signifies a strategic shift for both organizations. Carlton's gains from the trade are seen as providing flexibility to rebuild their list and invest in younger talent.

Conclusion and Unanswered Questions

The initial participation of Charlie Curnow in a match simulation with the Sydney Swans provides early data on his integration into the team. His performance was noted positively. The trade itself was a major event, involving substantial player and draft capital exchanges, highlighting the perceived value of Curnow to both his former and current clubs. While the move seems to align with Sydney's ambition for premiership contention and provides Carlton with resources for their future, the full ramifications of this significant player transfer will continue to unfold. Further details regarding the precise terms of the trade, beyond the initial reports of draft picks and player swaps, remain publicly unelaborated.

Read More: Nick Daicos stays at Collingwood after rejecting $5 million Tasmania offer in July 2025

Sources Used:

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What happened in the Sydney Swans practice match on February 20, 2025?
The Sydney Swans played an unofficial practice match against the Western Bulldogs at Whitten Oval. Charlie Curnow played for the Swans, showing the team's new forward line.
Q: Why did Charlie Curnow move to the Sydney Swans?
Charlie Curnow was traded from Carlton to the Sydney Swans. He wanted a new lifestyle and team. The Swans wanted to make their forward line stronger.
Q: How did Charlie Curnow play in his first match simulation for the Swans?
Reports said Charlie Curnow played very well in his first match simulation with the Sydney Swans. His performance was called 'sublime'.
Q: What was the trade deal for Charlie Curnow?
The trade between Carlton and Sydney for Charlie Curnow was a big deal. Carlton got draft picks and a young player. He is a two-time Coleman Medallist.
Q: Who was missing from the practice match on February 20, 2025?
The Swans missed Tom Papley, Justin McInerney, and Chad Warner. The Bulldogs were missing six Origin players and Adam Treloar.