Washington DC - Senior Pentagon officials are alleged to have invoked the historical subjugation of the papacy during a closed-door meeting in January, creating a rift with Vatican representatives. The reported incident involved discussions between U.S. defense officials and a Vatican ambassador, with U.S. officials described as "lecturing" the church representatives. This alleged exchange has been linked to the cancellation of a planned visit by Pope Leo XIV to the United States.
The core of the dispute appears to hinge on U.S. defense officials drawing a parallel between current geopolitical pressures and the 14th-century "Avignon Papacy," a period when the French monarchy exerted significant control over the Catholic Church, forcing its relocation from Rome.
Vice President JD Vance has publicly stated his intention to investigate the reported incident. He has previously engaged with Vatican officials, including meetings with Cardinal Pietro Parolin in April 2025, concerning policies of the Trump administration. At that time, Vatican figures, including Pope Leo XIV, had voiced criticisms of the administration's stances on issues such as immigration and foreign aid.
Read More: Greek Ministers Resign Over EU Farm Subsidy Investigation
Context of Papal Criticism and U.S. Actions
The alleged confrontation comes amid a backdrop of Pope Leo XIV’s vocal critiques of global conflicts and, specifically, U.S. foreign policy actions under the second Trump administration. Reports suggest the Pope had spoken out against actions such as the bombing of Iran’s nuclear facilities and other assertive U.S. foreign policy decisions.
The White House, through a statement to reporter Barbara Starr, has contested the characterization of the meeting, calling it "highly exaggerated and distorted." A Defense Department official described the meeting as "respectful and reasonable" and expressed continued high regard for dialogue with the Holy See.
Pope Leo XIV's Stance and U.S. Political Landscape
Pope Leo XIV, who succeeded Pope Francis, has been characterized as sensitive to the digital age and has urged leaders towards peace and the rejection of war. His papacy began in May 2025, and he is seen as likely to share Pope Francis’ priorities on social issues.
Read More: UK Leads 40+ Nations to Pressure Iran on Strait of Hormuz Reopening
The Vatican’s ambassador to the United States, Cardinal Christophe Pierre, was reportedly the target of the alleged U.S. official's remarks. The report suggests that Pope Leo XIV altered his travel plans, including a July 4th visit to the U.S., which was redirected to the Italian island of Lampedusa.
The circumstances surrounding the alleged "Avignon Papacy" invocation remain a point of contention, with differing accounts of the January meeting's tone and content. The incident has drawn attention from political figures like JD Vance, who has a history of engagement with Vatican officials on policy matters.
