New York baseball finds itself in an early-season mire, with both the Yankees and Mets mired in parallel losing streaks. Concurrently, a discussion is emerging around relief pitcher Mason Miller, whose early-season performance is prompting a conversation about his potential to challenge for the Cy Young award, a feat rarely accomplished by a reliever since 2003.
Miller's early season numbers are stark. He has recorded 19 strikeouts against just one walk, surrendering a mere single hit. His four-seam fastball is averaging over 101 mph, with some pitches even exceeding 102 mph. This dominance has placed him among the top contenders in early Cy Young odds, though the exact benchmarks for a reliever to make a serious run at the award remain subjects of debate, with suggestions pointing to ERA and WHIP figures as low as 0.60 and 0.70 respectively, alongside significant strikeout totals.
Read More: Murakami's 9 Home Runs Boost White Sox Offense in April 2026
Award Odds See Movement
Beyond the New York struggles and Miller's rise, the broader landscape of early season awards is also showing shifts. In the American League, Yordan Alvarez of the Astros has seen his MVP odds significantly improve. Conversely, Garrett Crochet of the Red Sox has experienced a tumble in his odds, replaced in prominence by Bryan Woo of the Mariners. The AL MVP race is tightening, with Aaron Judge extending his lead while Munetaka Murakami and Kevin McGonigle are now tied atop the odds board for MVP.
The Cy Young market also reflects early season performance. Tarik Skubal and Paul Skenes have both extended their leads in their respective leagues' Cy Young races. Skenes, in particular, has shown resilience after a rough opening day start against the Mets, bouncing back with strong performances in subsequent outings.
Emerging Talents and Player Narratives
The early narrative also includes players like JJ Wetherholt, whose composed approach to the game, honed through experience in various leagues, is noted. Wetherholt is described as the Yankees' best hitter this year and is noted for his calmness under pressure.
Elsewhere, discussions around potential stat leaders are underway. A player who finished second in strikeouts last season, and led the league in saves with a low ERA, is projected to continue strong performance. Another player, who tied for the league lead in stolen bases and hit a career-high 56 home runs last year, is also on radar.
Background and Historical Context
The Cy Young Award, named after Hall of Famer Cy Young, is presented annually to the best pitchers in Major League Baseball, one for the American League and one for the National League. Historically, only one rookie, Fernando Valenzuela in 1981, has won the award. Relievers have also won the award before, though it is uncommon. The Brooklyn/Los Angeles Dodgers franchise holds the record for the most Cy Young Awards by a team. The current season, however, is only a few weeks old, and significant shifts in performance and perception are still very much on the table.
Read More: Red Sox Call Up Rivera and Tolle Early Due to Team Changes