Massachusetts Governor Maura Healey has formally demanded that the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) provide comprehensive data on Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) arrests conducted within the state since January 2025. The request, delivered via a stern letter to DHS Secretary Kristi Noem and Acting ICE Director Todd Lyons, seeks specific details including individual identities, legal grounds for arrest, case status, detention locations, court jurisdictions, and hearing dates, all to be furnished within a week.
In response, ICE officials have publicly pointed to what they term an "irony," noting Governor Healey's own purported reluctance to share information with federal law enforcement while simultaneously demanding ICE's arrest records. ICE Boston, via their official account, tweeted a statement from Acting Director Todd Lyons and U.S. Attorney Leah Foley, questioning the governor's motives and her perceived efforts to "impede ICE from removing criminal illegal aliens."
Read More: Kansas Cancels 1,700 Transgender Driver's Licenses After New Law
The governor's office has not elaborated on the specific reasons for this demand for information. However, public records indicate a pattern of friction between Governor Healey's administration and ICE, particularly concerning the agency's operations within Massachusetts.
Governor's Stance on ICE Operations
Previous public statements from Governor Healey reveal concerns about ICE's enforcement tactics. In June 2025, she sought answers regarding the arrest of a Milford High School student, where other minors were reportedly released. Similar questions were raised in May 2025, following ICE operations on Nantucket and Martha's Vineyard, where approximately 40 individuals were apprehended. At that time, ICE noted that local authorities had been notified, a claim disputed by Island and state police, who stated they were not informed of the operations.
Furthermore, Governor Healey has taken executive action to limit ICE's presence in sensitive locations. In January 2026, she signed an executive order prohibiting new 287(g) agreements unless a public safety need is established. The order also restricts ICE civil arrests in non-public state facilities and prohibits the use of state property for immigration enforcement staging. This move was supported by organizations emphasizing the need for immigrant communities to feel safe in seeking healthcare and other services.
Read More: Texas Immigrant Family Freed From ICE Custody After Lawmaker Visits
Governor Healey has also expressed criticism regarding "collateral" arrests, where individuals without criminal records are apprehended during broader enforcement actions. She has previously stated support for arresting individuals with criminal records, regardless of immigration status, but has questioned ICE's methodology and transparency.
Background of Federal-State Tensions
The demands and responses highlight a broader, ongoing tension between state-level authorities and federal immigration enforcement agencies. Governor Healey, a Democrat, has previously aligned with "blue state" positions on immigration, sometimes clashing with federal policies. Reports from earlier in 2025 indicate concerns about ICE operations, including the arrest of a Tufts University graduate student and actions described as impacting individuals who were reportedly working and paying taxes in the state. These instances suggest a recurring pattern of the Governor's office seeking transparency and accountability from ICE, met with pushback regarding information sharing.
Read More: NACC Robodebt Report Questions Public Service Integrity After Findings
