Irish Dancing Rules Change for Transgender Competitors

A major Irish dancing group, CLRG, has decided that transgender dancers can compete in categories that match how they live their lives. This decision has caused many people to share different opinions about fairness in the sport.
By Newsroom | Sports, Social Issues |

A debate has intensified within the Irish dancing community following the success of a transgender dancer in qualifying for major female championships. The participation of transgender individuals in gender-specific sports categories has become a point of contention, with various groups voicing strong opinions and advocating for different policy approaches.

Irish dancing groups torched after trans dancer allowed to qualify for multiple female world championships - 1

Timeline of Events and Key Organizations

The current focus on transgender participation in Irish dance gained significant public attention in late 2023.

Irish dancing groups torched after trans dancer allowed to qualify for multiple female world championships - 2

  • November 2023: A transgender teenager, identified as Gabrielle Siegel in some reports, won a regional competition in the female category, securing a spot in the World Irish Dancing Championships. This victory sparked a wave of commentary and debate.

  • December 2023: Reports of the dancer's success and subsequent backlash circulated widely. Petitions were launched, with one titled "Protect Female Irish Dancers in Gender-Specific World Qualifying Championships Worldwide" gathering thousands of signatures, while another, "Support Transgender Irish Dancers," also garnered substantial support.

  • February 2024: An Coimisiún Le Rincí Gaelacha (CLRG), a primary governing body for Irish dance, announced it had made a decision to allow transgender dancers to compete in categories aligning with their gender identity. This followed legal advice and internal discussions.

  • March 2024: Discussions and analysis of the issue continued, with various perspectives being shared in public forums and media.

Read More: Hockey Star Jocelyne Larocque Wants More Indigenous Athletes to Succeed

Key Organizations Involved:

  • An Coimisiún Le Rincí Gaelacha (CLRG): The principal international governing body for competitive Irish dance, responsible for the World Irish Dancing Championships.

  • Irish Dance Teachers’ Association of North America (IDTANA): Another significant governing body in North America.

  • Concerned Women for America (CWA): A women's policy group that has actively criticized the policies allowing transgender participation.

  • Concerned Irish Dance Teachers, Adjudicators, Parents and Dancers: A group expressing concerns about fairness and a level playing field.

  • Various dancer and teacher groups: Many individuals within the Irish dance community have publicly shared their support for transgender inclusion or expressed concerns.

Evidence of Disagreement and Support

Public statements, petitions, and media reports illustrate a clear division of opinion.

Irish dancing groups torched after trans dancer allowed to qualify for multiple female world championships - 3

  • Concerns about Fair Competition:

  • Concerned Women for America (CWA) stated, "nine times out of 10, when boys are competing against girls in those local competitions, they win, purely because they do have greater endurance and greater capacity to do more of the tricks and complicated things in Irish dance than the girls do."

  • A group called Concerned Irish Dance Teachers, Adjudicators, Parents and Dancers believes, "separate competitions help ensure a level playing field where athletes can compete against others with similar biological characteristics."

  • One petition aimed to "Protect Female Irish Dancers in Gender-Specific World Qualifying Championships Worldwide," indicating a desire to maintain distinct categories for biological females.

  • Support for Transgender Inclusion:

  • CLRG's stated policy, as reported, allows dancers to enter competitions with the gender identity that aligns with their everyday public life.

  • A statement attributed to CLRG indicates they "recognize the right of transgender dancers to succeed in our sport, and celebrate their wins without exception."

  • An open letter, posted by dancer Gabrielle Siegel on behalf of teachers, adjudicators, dancers, and families, voiced "unequivocal support for transgender dancers and for these dancers to continue competing as their true selves in the category that best aligns with their gender identity."

  • A petition supporting transgender Irish dancers garnered over 7,200 signatures, demonstrating widespread backing for their inclusion.

Debates on Biological Differences and Sport Nature

Central to the debate are differing views on whether biological differences in Irish dance create an unequal playing field.

Read More: Karnataka Officials Tell Inspectors to Find More Child Labor Cases

Irish dancing groups torched after trans dancer allowed to qualify for multiple female world championships - 4

  • Arguments for No Biological Advantage:

  • Supporters of transgender inclusion assert that "Biological differences in Irish dance don't make an impact at all."

  • They argue that the judging and scoring in Irish dance do not inherently favor one biological sex over another, emphasizing skill, technique, and artistry.

  • Some statements suggest that any arguments about biological advantage are "not evidence-based, but don’t even apply to the way Irish dance is judged.”

  • Arguments for Biological Considerations:

  • Opponents of transgender participation in female categories often cite perceived differences in physical attributes like "endurance and capacity to do more of the tricks and complicated things" as creating an advantage.

  • The CWA blog post by Maggie McKneely framed Irish dance as a "highly gendered" sport, implying that such gendered structures should be maintained in competition.

CLRG's Policy and Internal Deliberations

The CLRG has affirmed its commitment to inclusivity following extensive consideration.

Read More: Many Couples Compete Together at the 2026 Winter Olympics

  • Policy Shift: The CLRG made a "landmark decision" to allow transgender dancers to compete in categories matching their gender identity.

  • Deliberation Process: This ruling followed legal advice, weeks of debate, and consideration of members' views. The organization reportedly held an "a half-day transgender educational forum" to examine research on transgender athletes, mixed competition results, and reputational risks.

  • Inclusivity Stance: The CLRG's position emphasizes advocating for "every one of our dancers" and supports transgender dancers succeeding in the sport.

Expert and Community Voices

A spectrum of opinions has been voiced by individuals and groups within and outside the Irish dance community.

  • Advocates for Inclusion:

  • Some dancers and teachers emphasize that Irish dance should be a safe space and that inclusion aligns with the spirit of the sport. One individual noted, "It doesn't even matter what you look like or how tall you are."

  • Support groups have emerged, with dancers standing "proudly" with trans competitors.

  • Critics and Concerned Parties:

  • Groups like CWA have actively campaigned against the current policies, raising concerns about the fairness for biological females.

  • Discussions on forums like Mumsnet indicate that the issue has caused significant debate and "upset" among some segments of the public and dance community.

  • PJ McCafferty, Southern regional director of the Irish Dance Teachers Association of North America, acknowledged the "great deal of upset" while confirming the commission's policy.

Conclusion and Implications

The controversy highlights a broader societal discussion about transgender inclusion in sports, particularly in activities historically organized along gender lines.

Read More: Labour Leader Starmer Says Reform UK Uses Racist Language

  • Divergent Views: The Irish dancing world appears divided, with strong arguments presented for both maintaining gender-segregated competitions based on biological sex and for allowing participation based on gender identity.

  • Governing Body's Decision: CLRG has formally adopted a policy favoring gender identity, seeking to balance inclusivity with the concerns raised by its members.

  • Ongoing Debate: Despite CLRG's decision, opposition and advocacy for differing policies persist. The situation underscores the complexities of integrating transgender athletes into competitive environments, particularly where perceptions of fair play are at stake. The differing stances on whether biological differences are a material factor in Irish dance scoring and performance will likely continue to fuel the discussion.

Sources Used:

Read More: Rugby League Games Have Unfair Calls, People Are Unhappy

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is the new rule in Irish dancing?
The main Irish dance group, CLRG, now allows transgender dancers to compete in categories that match their gender identity. This means they can join competitions as the gender they identify with.
Q: Why is this a big topic?
Some people worry this might not be fair for other dancers. Others believe it is important to include everyone and let them compete as themselves.
Q: What does CLRG say about the decision?
CLRG says they want to be fair and include all dancers. They have looked at advice and talked with many people before making this rule.
Q: Is everyone happy with this change?
No, there are different views. Some groups support the change for inclusion, while others have concerns about competition fairness.
Q: What happens next?
The debate continues, but CLRG's rule is now in place. This is part of a bigger talk about transgender people in sports.