God of War Sons of Sparta Release Date February 12 Changes Player Expectations

God of War Sons of Sparta launched Feb 12 with a Metacritic score of 66, lower than many other games in the series.
By Newsroom | Video Games, PlayStation |

A Surprise Release, A Mixed Reception

The recent release of God of War Sons of Sparta, a 2D side-scrolling spin-off, has sparked considerable discussion. Announced and released simultaneously during Sony's State of Play broadcast on February 12th, this "shadow-drop" strategy, while creating initial surprise, has coincided with a wave of mixed-to-negative reviews. The game, which explores the early lives of Kratos and his brother Deimos, holds a 66 Metacritic score based on 32 reviews at the time of reporting. This critical reception has led to an examination of the game's development, its fit within the established God of War universe, and the effectiveness of its surprise launch.

God of War Sons of Sparta reviews show why shadow-drops are bad - 1

Game Details and Release

God of War Sons of Sparta was announced and launched on the same day, February 12th, during a PlayStation State of Play event.

God of War Sons of Sparta reviews show why shadow-drops are bad - 2

  • It is a 2D side-scrolling game, a departure from the traditional 3D action-adventure style of the main God of War series.

  • The game is set in Ancient Greece and focuses on the Spartan youth of Kratos and his brother Deimos.

  • It was developed by Mega Cat Studios in conjunction with Sony Santa Monica Studio.

  • The game is available on PlayStation 5.

  • Some reports indicate the game features Metroidvania-like elements, focusing on exploration, combat, and puzzle-solving.

Developer and Publisher

  • Publisher: Sony Interactive Entertainment

  • Developer: Mega Cat Studios and Sony Santa Monica Studio

Critical Reception and Player Sentiment

The critical reception for God of War Sons of Sparta has been notably divided, with some outlets providing scores that place it among the lowest-rated entries in the franchise.

Read More: Fogpiercer Game Demo Lets Players Control a Train Deck to Fight Bandits

God of War Sons of Sparta reviews show why shadow-drops are bad - 3

  • Metacritic Score: 66 (based on 32 reviews)

  • OpenCritic Score: 70

  • User Scores: Some user scores on platforms like Metacritic and the PlayStation Store are reportedly better than critic scores, suggesting a segment of the player base finds value in the title.

Points of Contention: Franchise Fit and Gameplay

A significant aspect of the discussion surrounding Sons of Sparta revolves around whether the game successfully translates the essence of the God of War franchise into a 2D format.

God of War Sons of Sparta reviews show why shadow-drops are bad - 4

  • Creator's Criticism: David Jaffe, the original creator of God of War, has been vocal in his criticism, stating the game does not "respect the license" and feels like an "insult to fans."

  • He cited issues such as "confusing visual noise during combat," "gameplay breaking visual inconsistencies," a "buggy and confusing user interface," and concerns about "level design and character motion."

  • Jaffe also described the dialogue and voice acting as "kiddie level" and "generic boring."

  • Gameplay Mechanics: Reviewers have noted that while the game includes mechanics like parrying and dodging, the dodging often proves more beneficial. The gameplay has been described as playing it "too safe," lacking a distinctive edge.

  • Visuals and Presentation: Criticisms have been raised regarding "confusing visual noise" during combat and an overall visual presentation that some feel does not live up to the standards of either the God of War franchise or other modern 2D titles.

  • Dialogue and Story: The narrative has been characterized by some as "kiddie level dialogue," and concerns have been raised that the story does not align with the franchise's typical tone.

The "Shadow-Drop" Strategy Under Scrutiny

The decision to release God of War Sons of Sparta as a shadow drop, with no prior review embargoes, has also become a focal point of analysis.

  • Lack of Pre-Release Reviews: This strategy meant that players and critics alike had to form opinions based on immediate playtime, with no professional reviews available at launch.

  • Impact on Perception: The timing of the announcement and release, without substantial buildup or advance critical assessment, has been linked to the game's immediate critical reception and the subsequent discussions about its quality and suitability as a God of War title.

  • Return Policies: Platforms like Steam have standard return policies for games played for under two hours. This allows players to seek refunds if they are dissatisfied, a possibility that arises when the reception of a shadow-dropped game is lukewarm.

Expert Commentary and Developer Statements

The release and reception of God of War Sons of Sparta have drawn comments from industry figures and the developers.

  • David Jaffe's Concerns: As mentioned, Jaffe expressed strong dissatisfaction, comparing the game to a franchise license being used in a way that misrepresents its core identity. He stated the game was "not ready for release."

  • Sony Santa Monica Clarification: Sony Santa Monica was reportedly forced to clarify aspects of the game, specifically its two-player offering, following "widespread fan confusion." This suggests a potential disconnect between the game's presentation and player understanding.

  • Comparison to Other Titles: Some reviews have placed Sons of Sparta in comparison to other 2D titles like Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown and Hollow Knight: Silksong, suggesting it falls short of their quality and innovation.

Conclusion and Implications

The release of God of War Sons of Sparta has served as a case study in the potential pitfalls of the shadow-drop strategy, particularly when coupled with a significant departure from a beloved franchise's established formula.

Read More: God of War Creator Says New Game is 'Bad' and 'Insulting'

  • Strategic Risks: The surprise release, while intended to generate immediate buzz, has also been associated with a less-than-ideal critical reception, potentially limiting its long-term impact. The lack of pre-release reviews meant the game faced the public without the benefit of curated professional opinion, allowing immediate player feedback to shape its narrative.

  • Franchise Identity: The most persistent criticism centers on the game's perceived inability to capture the "God of War" spirit, leading to questions about creative direction and respect for the established license. Was the intention to expand the franchise in a new direction, or was this an attempt to leverage the brand on a title that, by some accounts, did not fully align with its core strengths?

  • Player Experience: While critical scores are lower, the existence of more favorable user scores indicates that the game may still find an audience, particularly among those less invested in the series' history or more open to its new interpretation. The clarity surrounding its two-player functionality was a necessary step to address player confusion.

  • Future Considerations: The reception of Sons of Sparta may prompt further consideration from developers and publishers regarding the balance between surprise launches and adequate preparation and promotion, as well as careful evaluation of how established IPs are adapted into new genres and formats.

Sources:

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: When was God of War Sons of Sparta released?
God of War Sons of Sparta was announced and released on the same day, February 12, during a PlayStation State of Play event. This surprise launch is known as a shadow drop.
Q: What kind of game is God of War Sons of Sparta?
This game is a 2D side-scrolling game, which is different from the usual 3D style of the main God of War series. It focuses on the early lives of Kratos and his brother Deimos in Ancient Greece.
Q: How did critics review God of War Sons of Sparta?
The game received mixed reviews, with a Metacritic score of 66 out of 100 from 32 reviews. Some people, like the original creator David Jaffe, said the game did not feel like a true God of War game and had many problems.
Q: Why are people talking about the shadow-drop strategy for this game?
The shadow-drop strategy meant the game came out with no warning or pre-release reviews. This led to players and critics forming opinions right away. Some think this strategy, combined with the game's mixed reception, hurt its launch.
Q: What are the main complaints about God of War Sons of Sparta?
People are unhappy with how the game looks during fights, its confusing menus, and the story and voice acting, which some call childish. They also question if a 2D game can truly capture the spirit of the God of War series.
Q: Will God of War Sons of Sparta be available for a long time?
The game is available on PlayStation 5. Some players who are not happy with the game can ask for refunds if they have played for less than two hours, which is a common policy on platforms like Steam.