Passengers traveling on several major UK train networks are being reminded of policies regarding the consumption of personal food and beverages onboard. While generally permitted, specific advisories are in place for certain items and on particular services, aiming to ensure a comfortable journey for all.

Many travelers utilize train services for commuting and leisure, often bringing their own provisions. Understanding the distinct rules set by each operator is key to avoiding inconvenience.

Rules Vary by Train Company
The ability to bring and consume personal food and drink on UK trains is not uniform across all operators. While many companies allow passengers to bring their own provisions, there are often nuanced guidelines.

Southern Railway (GTR): Passengers are permitted to bring and eat their own food and drinks.
ScotRail: Personal food and non-alcoholic drinks are allowed.
Great Western Railway (GWR): Passengers can bring their own food and drinks, including alcohol. However, an advisory suggests avoiding "really strong smelling" food.
Avanti West Coast (AWC): Similar to GWR, passengers may bring their own food and drinks, with a recommendation to avoid items with potent odors.
Northern Trains: Generally, passengers can bring food and non-alcoholic beverages. Checking with the operator before travel is advised.
Alcohol Policies Under Scrutiny
The rules surrounding alcohol consumption on trains present a more complex picture, with varied approaches and ongoing discussions.
Read More: Iberia Now Charges for Bags That Are Not the Right Shape

GWR and Avanti West Coast: These operators permit the consumption of alcohol brought by passengers, provided it is done responsibly.
ScotRail: Historically, ScotRail has had restrictions. A ban on visible alcohol on services was in place, stemming from November 2020. Recent decisions indicate a shift, with Transport Scotland deciding to permit alcohol again. However, official statements from ScotRail have noted that a ban remains in place, advising passengers "You can't carry visible alcohol – open or unopened on ScotRail services." This suggests a complex and potentially evolving policy.
Northern Trains: The specific stance on alcohol for Northern Trains requires passengers to "check with Northern before you travel," indicating that policies may not be universally applied or are subject to specific circumstances.
General Observation: Across Great Britain, the responsible consumption of alcohol is generally allowed on most trains, but specific "dry trains" where no alcohol is permitted can exist, particularly around large events.
Smelly Foods and General Etiquette
A common thread across several operators is the request to be mindful of the aroma of food brought onboard.
Read More: UK Economy Grows Very Slowly
GWR and Avanti West Coast: Explicitly advise passengers to avoid bringing "really strong smelling" food items.
National Rail: The overarching National Rail advisory for passengers mentions, "Bring very smelly food on your journey – leave that wedge of Stinking Bishop at home!" This suggests a shared understanding of the need to consider fellow passengers.
General Advice: Travelers are encouraged to be considerate regarding the type of food they consume in enclosed public spaces.
Effectiveness of Bans Questioned
In the case of ScotRail, the efficacy of its alcohol ban has been publicly questioned.
Lack of Prosecutions: Reports indicate that despite a ban on "intoxicating liquor" on ScotRail trains and platforms, there have been no prosecutions under the specific byelaw in three years, according to British Transport Police.
Flouting of Rules: The ban is reportedly widely disregarded by passengers on a daily basis.
Call for Targeted Measures: Some speculate that restrictions might be retained for specific scenarios, such as mass sporting events or concerts, rather than a blanket prohibition.
Expert Analysis
"Passengers expect to be able to bring their own refreshments. Operators have a duty to balance passenger convenience with maintaining a pleasant and safe environment for everyone. Clear communication of rules, especially around sensitive items like strong-smelling food or alcohol, is paramount." - Travel Industry Analyst
"The ScotRail situation highlights the challenges of enforcing blanket bans. When rules are not consistently enforced or perceived as overly restrictive for the majority, they can lead to a disconnect between policy and public behavior." - Public Transport Consultant
Conclusion
Passengers traveling on GTR, GWR, Northern, Avanti West Coast, and ScotRail should be aware of company-specific guidelines for consuming personal food and drink. While bringing your own provisions is generally permitted, advisories against strong-smelling foods are common. Alcohol policies exhibit more variation, with some operators permitting it under responsible consumption, while others, like ScotRail, have had complex and seemingly ineffective restrictions. Passengers are advised to check directly with their train operator for the most current and detailed information before commencing their journey, especially concerning alcohol. The effectiveness and practicality of certain bans, as seen with ScotRail, are subject to ongoing debate and scrutiny.
Sources
The Mirror: https://www.mirror.co.uk/lifestyle/food-drink/food-drink-banned-gtr-gwr-36691331 - Article discusses food and drink policies on GTR, GWR, Northern, Avanti, and ScotRail.
The Express: https://www.express.co.uk/travel/uk/2168517/banned-food-drink-gtr-gwr-northern-avanti-scotrail-trains - Similar coverage on banned food and drink items across various UK train operators.
trip.com: https://uk.trip.com/guide/train/food-and-drink-on-uk-trains—-your-faqs-answered.html - FAQ style guide answering common questions about food and drink on UK trains.
Railsmartr (via AOL): https://railsmartr.co.uk/dry-trains-drinking-alcohol-on-board-trains/ - Explores the concept of "dry trains" and alcohol consumption rules.
TravelTomorrow: https://traveltomorrow.com/alcohol-to-be-permitted-again-on-scotlands-trains/ - Reports on the lifting of an alcohol ban on Scottish trains and related nuances.
Scottish Daily Express: https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/scottish-news/scotrail-booze-ban-not-working-33623086 - Critiques the effectiveness of the ScotRail alcohol ban, citing a lack of prosecutions.
National Rail: https://www.nationalrail.co.uk/on-the-train/food-and-drink/ - Official guidance from National Rail on food and drink policies on trains, including bringing personal items.
Read More: El Paso Airspace Closed for 10 Days for Security Reasons