UK High Court Stops Chagos Islands Transfer to Mauritius on May 22, 2025

A UK court has stopped the Chagos Islands transfer to Mauritius, delaying the deal announced in May 2025. This is a change from the original plan.
By Newsroom | Law, Politics |

A recent court decision has put a temporary pause on the United Kingdom's agreement to hand over the Chagos Islands to Mauritius. This ruling follows a legal challenge from some Chagossian people who were previously removed from their homeland. The situation remains complex, with ongoing efforts by the UK government to finalize the transfer while facing opposition and legal hurdles.

Deportation of Chagos Islanders blocked by judge - 1

The Chagos Islands, a territory administered by the UK, have been a point of contention for decades. In the 1960s and 1970s, the Chagossian population was removed from the islands to make way for a joint UK-US military base on Diego Garcia. Now, an agreement has been reached between the UK and Mauritius for the transfer of sovereignty. However, this deal has been met with legal challenges, particularly from Chagossian individuals and groups who see it as a betrayal of their rights and a denial of their hope to return home.

Read More: UK Athletics Admits Corporate Manslaughter in 2017 Death of Paralympian Abdullah Hayayei in London

Deportation of Chagos Islanders blocked by judge - 2

Background of the Chagos Islands Dispute

The history of the Chagos Islands is marked by forced displacement and international legal disputes.

Deportation of Chagos Islanders blocked by judge - 3

  • Forced Removal: Between the mid-1960s and early 1970s, the British government forcibly removed the indigenous population, the Chagossians, from their islands. This was done to establish a military base, primarily on Diego Garcia, which is now used by the United States.

  • International Rulings: Both the International Court of Justice (ICJ) and the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea (ITLS) have previously ruled that the separation of the Chagos Islands from Mauritius during decolonization was unlawful. These rulings suggest that the islands legally belong to Mauritius.

  • UK-Mauritius Agreement: Despite international pressure and legal opinions, the UK government reached an agreement with Mauritius. This deal, announced in May 2025, aims to recognize Mauritius's sovereignty over the islands. In return, the UK would lease back the base on Diego Garcia for 99 years.

  • Chagossian Hopes: Many Chagossians, who now reside in the UK, Mauritius, and Seychelles, view the potential transfer with dismay. While some Chagossians support the deal, seeing it as a path to resolving the sovereignty dispute, others feel betrayed and desire to return to their homeland, hoping the UK retains control.

A recent court decision has temporarily halted the UK's plan to transfer the Chagos Islands to Mauritius.

Deportation of Chagos Islanders blocked by judge - 4

  • Court Orders: On May 22, 2025, a High Court judge in London granted an emergency injunction. This order prevents the UK from finalizing the handover of sovereignty to Mauritius, pending a full judicial review of the agreement.

  • Legal Challenge: The injunction came after a legal challenge was filed by Chagossian individuals. In one instance, four men were served with eviction papers warning of fines or jail if they did not leave the islands. They were granted at least an additional seven days on the island by the BIOT Supreme Court. Another legal challenge was brought by two Chagossian women living in the UK.

  • Temporary Relief: The court's decision provides temporary relief for the Chagossian individuals involved in the legal action, granting them more time on the islands.

Conflicting Interests and Perspectives

The Chagos Islands situation involves deeply held beliefs and conflicting interests among various parties.

UK Government's Stance

  • International Law: The UK government, led by Prime Minister Keir Starmer, has stated that international legal rulings have cast doubt on Britain's ownership of the Chagos Islands.

  • Strategic Importance: To ensure the continued functionality of the military base on Diego Garcia and its satellite communications, a deal with Mauritius was deemed necessary by the UK government.

  • Avoiding Piracy/Rival Bases: Without an agreement, the UK could not prevent other nations, such as China, from establishing bases or conducting exercises near British interests.

Chagossian Community Views

  • Desire to Return: Many Chagossians see the islands as their homeland and wish to return. They feel the current deal is a betrayal of their rights.

  • Differing Opinions: It is important to note that the Chagossian community is not monolithic in its views. While some oppose the deal and want the UK to retain sovereignty, others may view the agreement with Mauritius differently, perhaps seeking resolution or recognizing the legal complexities.

  • Human Rights Concerns: Some Chagossians believe the British government is disregarding their human rights by proceeding with the transfer.

Mauritius's Position

  • Sovereignty Claims: Mauritius has long claimed sovereignty over the Chagos Islands, viewing them as illegally separated territory.

  • Deal as Resolution: The agreement with the UK is seen by Mauritius as a step towards resolving the long-standing territorial dispute.

Expert Analysis

The legal and political ramifications of the Chagos Islands dispute are significant.

"The court's intervention highlights the ongoing complexities and the deep-seated grievances surrounding the Chagos Islands. While the UK seeks to resolve a long-standing territorial dispute and secure strategic interests, the rights and historical claims of the Chagossian people remain central to the legal challenges."

This ruling indicates that any transfer of sovereignty will likely face further scrutiny, and the rights of the Chagossian people will be a critical factor in any future resolution.

Findings and Implications

The recent court decision has created a temporary setback for the UK government's plan to transfer the Chagos Islands to Mauritius.

  • Immediate Impact: The immediate impact is a delay in the finalization of the agreement, granting Chagossian individuals involved in the legal action more time on the islands.

  • Judicial Review: The case will now proceed to a full judicial review, where the legality and fairness of the UK-Mauritius deal will be examined more thoroughly.

  • Uncertainty: The future of the Chagos Islands' sovereignty remains uncertain, contingent on the outcome of the judicial review and any subsequent legal or political developments.

  • Humanitarian Dimension: The situation underscores the persistent humanitarian concerns for the Chagossian people, whose history is intertwined with forced displacement and a desire for their homeland.

The UK government's efforts to hand over control of the islands to Mauritius are now further complicated by this judicial intervention. The case is expected to draw significant attention, focusing on the intersection of international law, national security, and the human rights of displaced populations.

Read More: Texas Republicans redraw districts, making it harder for Democrats to win seats in 2026

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Why did a UK court stop the Chagos Islands transfer to Mauritius on May 22, 2025?
A High Court judge in London granted an emergency order on May 22, 2025, to stop the UK from finalizing the handover of the Chagos Islands to Mauritius. This happened after Chagossian people filed legal challenges.
Q: Who is affected by the court's decision on May 22, 2025, about the Chagos Islands?
Chagossian people who were removed from their homeland are directly affected. Some of them were facing eviction from the islands. The court's order gives them temporary relief and more time on the islands while the case is reviewed.
Q: What happens next with the UK's plan to transfer the Chagos Islands to Mauritius after the May 22, 2025, court ruling?
The court's decision means the transfer is delayed. The case will now go through a full judicial review. This review will look closely at the UK-Mauritius agreement. The future of the islands' control is now uncertain until this review is finished.
Q: What was the reason for the UK's agreement to transfer the Chagos Islands to Mauritius?
The UK government agreed to transfer sovereignty to Mauritius partly because of international court rulings saying the islands belong to Mauritius. The UK also wanted to keep using the military base on Diego Garcia, which is part of the islands, through a long-term lease. This agreement was seen as a way to solve a long-standing territorial dispute and protect UK interests.
Q: What do Chagossian people think about the court's decision on May 22, 2025, regarding the islands?
Many Chagossian people who want to return to their homeland are happy with the court's temporary block. They see the transfer deal as unfair. However, the Chagossian community has different views, and not all agree on the best way forward. The court's decision gives them more time to fight for their rights.