Nathan Cleary faces ban for high tackle before NRL season opener vs Broncos

Nathan Cleary is at risk of suspension for a high tackle in a pre-season game. This could mean he misses the NRL season opener.
By Newsroom | Sports, Rugby League |

Penrith Panthers star Nathan Cleary is facing an uncertain future regarding his participation in the team's opening NRL match of the season. A recent incident during a pre-season game has placed him on report, raising questions about a possible suspension that could impact his team's crucial first outing against the Brisbane Broncos. The outcome of the NRL's match review committee's findings will determine whether the acclaimed halfback will be available for this significant fixture.

Background of the Incident

The event occurred during a pre-season challenge match between the Penrith Panthers and the Wests Tigers at Leichhardt Oval. Nathan Cleary, captain of the Panthers, was involved in an on-field incident with Wests Tigers rookie Heamasi Makasini. During the game, Cleary made contact with Makasini in what was later described as a high shot.

Nathan Cleary in doubt for Penrith’s opener - 1

  • Following the impact, Heamasi Makasini was assessed but was able to continue playing.

  • The referee, Ashley Klein, placed Cleary on report for the incident.

  • Cleary was subsequently sent off the field for a 10-minute period in the sin-bin.

  • Nathan Cleary reportedly apologized to Heamasi Makasini shortly after the event.

  • The Wests Tigers’ left edge, featuring players like Jarome Luai, Samuela Fainu, Taylan May, and Makasini, is noted for its potential to score points if they remain fit.

Implications for the Penrith Panthers

The potential absence of Nathan Cleary carries significant weight for the Panthers, especially considering the team's challenging draw for the start of the season.

Read More: Maro Itoje Becomes England Rugby Captain After Mother's Death and Past Doubts

  • Cleary is widely recognized as one of the sport's elite players.

  • His leadership and on-field performance are considered vital to the Panthers' strategy and success.

  • A suspension would force the team to adapt their lineup for a high-stakes opening game against the reigning premiers.

Player History and Precedent

Nathan Cleary has a history of outstanding performances and has achieved significant milestones in his career.

Nathan Cleary in doubt for Penrith’s opener - 2

  • In the previous season, Cleary led the Panthers from a difficult position to a preliminary final, showcasing exceptional leadership.

  • He holds the record for the most points scored for the Penrith Panthers, surpassing Ryan Girdler.

  • Cleary has received major individual awards, including the Merv Cartwright Medal multiple times and the Dally M Halfback of the Year.

  • He is known for his dedication to his physical conditioning and recovery, with teammates noting his meticulous approach to diet, sleep, and training, often to prepare for important matches.

Match Review Process and Anticipated Outcome

The decision regarding Nathan Cleary's availability rests with the NRL's match review committee, which is expected to deliver its findings.

  • The committee will review the incident involving Cleary and Makasini.

  • They will determine if there is sufficient evidence to lay a charge and, if so, what the grading of that charge will be.

  • Penalties for such incidents can range from fines to suspensions, depending on the severity and nature of the contact.

  • Both Cleary and the Penrith Panthers are awaiting the official ruling.

Expert Analysis

"He’s doing everything in his power to be right (for round 1) and hopefully he’ll be there. His diligence is second to none and he does everything in his power." - Teammate, regarding Cleary's recovery and preparation.

This statement from a teammate underscores Cleary's commitment to being available for key matches. His meticulous approach to his physical condition is highlighted, suggesting a strong desire to overcome any potential barriers to participation.

Conclusion

The immediate focus for the Penrith Panthers and their supporters is the impending decision from the NRL's match review committee. The incident involving Nathan Cleary and Heamasi Makasini has placed the team's captain in a precarious position ahead of their season opener against the Brisbane Broncos. While Cleary has a reputation for diligent preparation and recovery, the on-field action has led to an official review. The outcome will dictate whether a key player is sidelined for a critical match, a scenario that would undoubtedly present a considerable challenge for the Panthers.

Read More: Penrith Panthers star Nathan Cleary sin-binned for high tackle, faces uncertain start to season

Sources:

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Why is Nathan Cleary in doubt for the NRL season opener against the Broncos?
Nathan Cleary was placed on report for a high tackle during a pre-season game against the Wests Tigers. The NRL's match review committee will decide if he faces a suspension.
Q: What happened during the incident involving Nathan Cleary?
Cleary made contact with Wests Tigers player Heamasi Makasini in what was described as a high shot. Makasini was checked but continued playing, and Cleary was sent to the sin-bin for 10 minutes.
Q: Could Nathan Cleary be suspended for the first game of the NRL season?
Yes, the outcome of the NRL's match review committee findings will determine if Cleary is suspended. A ban would mean he misses the important opening match against the Brisbane Broncos.
Q: How important is Nathan Cleary to the Penrith Panthers?
Nathan Cleary is considered one of the best players in the NRL and is vital for the Panthers' strategy and leadership. His absence would be a big challenge for the team, especially for their tough opening game.
Q: Has Nathan Cleary apologized for the incident?
Yes, Nathan Cleary reportedly apologized to Heamasi Makasini shortly after the on-field incident occurred.