Sleep apps may cause more worry for people with insomnia

New research suggests sleep tracking apps can cause more worry for people with insomnia. About 17% of users reported increased sleep anxiety.
By Newsroom | Health, Technology |

THE PROMISE AND PERIL OF TRACKING SLUMBER

Research emerging recently indicates a significant drawback to the ubiquitous sleep-tracking applications: while beneficial for some, these digital aids are increasingly shown to exacerbate stress and anxiety among individuals grappling with insomnia. The core of the issue lies in the inaccurate or overwhelming data these apps can present, leading to increased worry about sleep patterns rather than fostering genuine rest.

Sleep apps are good for maintaining a healthy routine, but they stress out insomniacs - 1

A study examining the use of sleep apps reveals a stark dichotomy in user experience. For a portion of users, these applications provide valuable insights into their sleep habits, contributing to a healthier routine. However, a notable percentage, particularly those suffering from insomnia, report a negative impact. The very tools designed to promote better sleep are, paradoxically, creating a feedback loop of anxiety about sleep quality. This is often due to the apps not providing a precise picture of sleep, thereby fueling concerns rather than offering solutions.

Read More: UK Healthy Years Drop by 20 Years for Poor Areas

Sleep apps are good for maintaining a healthy routine, but they stress out insomniacs - 2

THE DATA'S DAMAGING EFFECT

Concerns center on the accuracy of the sleep data generated by these apps. While some users find comfort in understanding their sleep stages and duration, insomniacs may find the presented information a source of increased pressure. Worrying more about sleep was cited as a common negative effect by users, with some studies indicating that this anxiety can directly impede restful sleep. This highlights a critical paradox: the pursuit of sleep optimization through technology may be actively sabotaging the very goal it aims to achieve for a vulnerable demographic.

Sleep apps are good for maintaining a healthy routine, but they stress out insomniacs - 3

  • Approximately 15 percent of respondents in one survey found their sleep improved with app use.

  • Conversely, 2.3 percent reported worse sleep.

  • A significant 17 percent identified increased worry about sleep as the primary negative outcome.

THE WIDER LANDSCAPE OF SLEEP ASSISTANCE

Beyond the direct impact on insomniacs, the proliferation of sleep apps taps into a broader societal interest in sleep health. These applications offer a range of functionalities, from guided meditations and sleep music aimed at calming the mind, to detailed sleep cycle tracking and customized reports. They are presented as solutions for a variety of sleep-related issues, from environmental noise disruption to general anxiety, promising improved sleep hygiene and routines.

Read More: Oprah Winfrey's Media Moves to Amazon Platforms Starting July

Sleep apps are good for maintaining a healthy routine, but they stress out insomniacs - 4

Historically, the push for sleep-related technology has seen a surge, with a wide array of apps entering the market. These range from those offering soundscapes to mask external disturbances, to more complex programs providing structured, multi-week plans for sleep improvement. Some experts even recommend specific apps for their potential in cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia (CBT-I) approaches.

  • Sleep apps often aim to help users fall asleep, stay asleep, or monitor vital signs.

  • Features include easy-to-read sleep graphs, insights into sleep stages, and ambient sound recordings.

  • Older articles from 2020 highlight a market already rich with options, suggesting a sustained interest in digital sleep aids.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How can sleep tracking apps affect people with insomnia?
New research shows that while some users benefit, sleep tracking apps can actually increase worry and anxiety for people with insomnia. This is often because the data provided by the apps can be inaccurate or overwhelming.
Q: Why do sleep apps cause more worry for some people?
The apps may not give a precise picture of sleep, leading users to focus too much on their sleep patterns. This increased worry can make it harder to fall asleep, creating a cycle of anxiety.
Q: What percentage of users report negative effects from sleep apps?
One survey found that about 17 percent of users reported increased worry about sleep as the main negative outcome from using sleep apps. Only about 15 percent found their sleep improved.
Q: What is the main problem with sleep app data?
The accuracy of the sleep data generated by these apps is a major concern. For individuals struggling with insomnia, the information can add pressure rather than offer solutions for better sleep.
Q: Are there any benefits to using sleep apps?
Yes, some users find sleep apps helpful for understanding their sleep habits and improving their routines. Apps offer features like guided meditations and sleep music to help users relax and potentially sleep better.