Four Contenders Vie for Scottish Football Writers' Association Accolade
The Scottish Football Writers' Association (SFWA) has unveiled its shortlist for Manager of the Year. Jens Berthel Askou, John McGlynn, Derek McInnes, and Martin O'Neill are the four individuals in contention for the prestigious award. The announcement comes just weeks after the PFA Scotland Manager of the Year nominations were revealed, a list that notably excluded Askou.
The SFWA's selection places Askou, O'Neill, McGlynn, and McInnes in direct competition, a contrast to the PFA Scotland shortlist which focused on McInnes, McGlynn, and Gary Naysmith, sparking debate about managerial recognition across different bodies.
Managerial Feats and Omissions
Jens Berthel Askou, manager of Motherwell, has been recognized by the SFWA despite being a "notable omission" from the PFA Scotland list. His work with Motherwell has been lauded for guiding the club to fourth in the Scottish Premiership, with periods where they were considered potential title contenders due to their "expansive and effective football." Askou himself commented on the PFA omission, stating that while he believes McInnes, McGlynn, and Naysmith "really deserve the recognition," it is "very cool that a manager from not necessarily the top league also gets some recognition." He emphasized the importance of attracting new players through positive club environments and player development.
Read More: Cowboys vs Giants 2026 NFL Season Opener on Sunday Night Football
Derek McInnes, currently at Hearts, is also a prominent figure on both shortlists. He has led Hearts to the top of the Premiership, enjoying a strong position with just four games remaining. His successful tenure has been marked by significant points accumulation since his arrival in October, turning an eighth-placed team into title challengers.
John McGlynn of Falkirk features on both the SFWA and PFA Scotland lists. He has guided Falkirk to a top-six finish in the Scottish Premiership following back-to-back promotions, marking their return to the top flight. McGlynn was the recipient of the PFA prize last week, having previously secured an "invincible League 1-winning campaign."
Martin O'Neill, another nominee for the SFWA award, was also mentioned in initial reports alongside Askou for the SFWA award. Details regarding his specific managerial achievements for this period were less prominent in the provided articles, though his presence on the SFWA shortlist signifies a level of recognition for his work.
Read More: Barcelona Wins 29th La Liga Title After Beating Real Madrid 2-0
Contrasting Award Criteria and Previous Winners
The divergence in nominations between the SFWA and PFA Scotland highlights potentially different evaluation metrics for managerial success. While the PFA list prominently featured McInnes, McGlynn, and Gary Naysmith (manager of Stenhousemuir), the SFWA has broadened the scope to include Askou and O'Neill.
In recent years, Derek McInnes has been a consistent figure in managerial award discussions. In May 2024, he was named the SFWA Manager of the Year, beating out strong competition from Philippe Clement, John McGlynn, and Tony Docherty. He expressed being "thrilled" and "totally appreciative" of the accolade.
The award ceremonies underscore the competitive landscape of Scottish football management, with different bodies acknowledging varying aspects of a manager's contribution throughout the season. The inclusion of SWPL managers for the first time also signals an evolving approach to recognizing talent across the sport.
Read More: Tasmania AFL Coach Talks: Hinkley Hints at Talks, Indigenous Issues Grow
