Seinfeld Creator Says Prison Ending Was The Only Mistake

The Seinfeld finale, which aired 28 years ago, had 76 million viewers but Jerry Seinfeld now calls the characters' prison sentence the show's only mistake.

Jerry Seinfeld, now 72, has revisited the widely debated ending of his eponymous sitcom, identifying the characters' imprisonment as the show's singular misstep. This reflection emerges 28 years after "The Finale" aired, a broadcast that drew an audience of 76 million viewers but ultimately divided fans and critics alike.

FA Youth Cup Final: Manchester City U18s 2-1 Manchester United U18s - 1

The core contention, as voiced by Seinfeld, centers on the decision to have the main characters incarcerated at the episode's conclusion. He expressed this view in recent discussions, including an appearance on the Q with Tom Powers podcast and during reflections tied to the final season of Curb Your Enthusiasm. The "only mistake," according to Seinfeld, was "leaving them in jail."

FA Youth Cup Final: Manchester City U18s 2-1 Manchester United U18s - 2

The polarizing nature of the Seinfeld finale has persisted through the decades. The episode, structured as a clip show retrospective, focused on consequences and deviated from the show's typical lighthearted resolutions, a departure many viewers found unsatisfying. Seinfeld and co-creator Larry David have both faced mixed responses over the years regarding this final narrative choice.

Read More: Donald Gibb 'Ogre' Actor Dies at 71 in Texas

FA Youth Cup Final: Manchester City U18s 2-1 Manchester United U18s - 3

Interestingly, the conclusion of Curb Your Enthusiasm offered a narrative callback, a "joke 26 years in the making" according to co-creator Jeff Schaffer. In this Curb finale, Larry is sentenced to jail, only to be freed by a mistrial declared by Jerry, who appears with the news. Schaffer noted that the idea for this meta-referential ending, connecting the two series across a significant time gap, occurred spontaneously. Seinfeld commented on this later resolution, questioning, "Why didn't we do it?" implying it could have provided a different kind of closure.

FA Youth Cup Final: Manchester City U18s 2-1 Manchester United U18s - 4

Despite the criticisms surrounding its ending, Seinfeld remains an influential and foundational sitcom with a lasting cultural impact, having amassed 72 award wins from numerous nominations throughout its run.

Read More: Jenna Elfman Continues TV Acting After 90s Sitcom Fame

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What did Jerry Seinfeld say was the only mistake in the Seinfeld finale?
Jerry Seinfeld, 28 years after the finale aired, said the only mistake was sending the main characters to prison at the end.
Q: Why did Seinfeld think the prison ending was a mistake?
Seinfeld felt the prison ending was a mistake because it was a departure from the show's usual lighthearted resolutions and left viewers unsatisfied.
Q: How did the Curb Your Enthusiasm finale connect to Seinfeld's ending?
The Curb Your Enthusiasm finale showed Larry David going to jail, but Jerry Seinfeld appeared to tell him about a mistrial, a joke 26 years in the making.
Q: What is the lasting impact of the Seinfeld show?
Despite the debated ending, Seinfeld remains a very important and influential sitcom that won 72 awards during its run.