Reece Walsh: Good Player, But Makes Big Mistakes

Reece Walsh is a talented player in the NRL. He can do amazing things on the field, like scoring tries. However, he has also made big mistakes that have hurt his team. This report looks at his good and bad moments.
By Newsroom | NRL, Rugby League |

Walsh's Impact in NRL Games: A Mix of Brilliance and Mistakes

Recent NRL matches show Reece Walsh as a player capable of significant impact, yet also prone to critical errors. In a recent preseason game, a player named Joey Walsh was noted for a towering kick that led to a score for the Manly Sea Eagles against the New Zealand Warriors. However, this Joey Walsh appears to be distinct from the Reece Walsh who, in April 2025, had a mixed night. In that game, Reece Walsh suffered an injury scare but continued playing, even inspiring his team in attack. This same Reece Walsh was later involved in a golden point loss for the Warriors, where a costly kick-off error helped the opposing team secure victory.

LIVE NRL: ‘Doing the damage’ — Walsh magic as Manly halves shine to dominate Warriors - 1

Context of Walsh's NRL Career

The available reports paint a picture of a dynamic career for Reece Walsh, involving both high points and challenging moments.

Read More: Payne Haas Will Leave Broncos for Rabbitohs

LIVE NRL: ‘Doing the damage’ — Walsh magic as Manly halves shine to dominate Warriors - 2

  • Early Career and Benching: In July 2022, an article noted that Reece Walsh, then described as a "young gun" for the Warriors, was "brutally benched" by interim coach Stacey Jones for a match against the Raiders. This suggests a period of scrutiny or a need for adjustment early in his NRL journey.

  • Club Debut and Milestone Moments: In September 2025, a player named Joey Walsh debuted off the bench for Manly Sea Eagles, seen as a glimpse into the future. This Joey Walsh seems to be a different player than Reece Walsh. In contrast, Daly Cherry-Evans marked his final game for Manly with a match-winning field goal.

  • Brisbane Broncos' Performance: In July 2025, Reece Walsh was instrumental in the Brisbane Broncos securing their fifth consecutive win, scoring a "beauty" of a try. His efforts were praised, with him heaping praise on the forward pack.

  • Coaching Decisions and Injuries: In April 2025, Broncos coach Michael Maguire admitted to still working out his team's "spine" (key playmakers). He noted an "issue" for Reece Walsh, who picked up a knee injury early in a match and had "not been at his best this season," despite showing class by setting up and scoring a try.

  • Crucial Errors in Close Games: The same April 2025 report highlights Reece Walsh going from "hero to zero." His kick-off sailed over the dead ball line at the start of extra time, gifting the Warriors a chance to win, which they capitalized on. This error occurred in a game where the Warriors ultimately won in golden point.

Key Incidents and Player Performances

Match ContextKey Player(s)EventOutcomeArticle Reference
Pre-season Challenge: Warriors vs ManlyJoey Walsh, Hugo HartJoey Walsh kick leads to try from a drop out.Manly led 26-14.1
Warriors vs Broncos (Golden Point)Reece Walsh, Luke MetcalfReece Walsh costly kick-off error; Luke Metcalf penalty goal.Warriors won in golden point.2, 7
Warriors vs Raiders (2022)Reece WalshReece Walsh benched by coach Stacey Jones.Not specified.3
Manly vs Warriors (DCE's Farewell)Joey Walsh, Daly Cherry-EvansJoey Walsh debuted off the bench; DCE kicked match-winning field goal.Manly won narrowly.4
Broncos vs TitansReece WalshReece Walsh scored a try.Broncos won, securing fifth-straight win.5
Broncos vs Warriors (Injury Scare)Reece Walsh, Michael MaguireReece Walsh injured early, showed class with try assist/score.Broncos lost; coach Maguire discussed spine issues.6
Warriors vs Broncos (Golden Point Epic)Reece Walsh, CapewellReece Walsh's kick-off error gifted possession; Capewell tackled him.Warriors won in golden point.7
General NRL Discussion (Talking Points)Reece WalshDiscussed as a potential contender for Blues halves if fit.Not directly linked to a specific match event.8

Examining Walsh's Role and Impact

Defensive Vulnerabilities and Attacking Spark

In the April 2025 clash between the Warriors and Broncos, Reece Walsh's performance was marked by both his ability to create and a critical defensive lapse. After an injury scare early in the game, he returned to inspire his team in attack. However, the match culminated in a golden point scenario where his kick-off went over the dead ball line. This mistake gifted the Warriors possession, directly leading to the penalty goal that sealed their victory. One could question if the physical toll of the earlier injury influenced his decision-making or execution during this crucial moment.

Read More: Knights Play Bulldogs Before Las Vegas Trip

LIVE NRL: ‘Doing the damage’ — Walsh magic as Manly halves shine to dominate Warriors - 3

Coaching Confidence and Player Development

The decision by interim Warriors coach Stacey Jones to bench Reece Walsh in July 2022, labeling it "brutal," indicates a period where the young player was under pressure. This contrasts with his later impact at the Brisbane Broncos, where he was instrumental in securing wins and was even considered for higher representative honors. Did this benching serve as a catalyst for his development, or was it indicative of deeper issues at that stage of his career?

LIVE NRL: ‘Doing the damage’ — Walsh magic as Manly halves shine to dominate Warriors - 4

The Case of "Joey Walsh"

The mention of a player named Joey Walsh in a preseason match between the Warriors and Manly Sea Eagles raises a point of clarity. This Joey Walsh is credited with a significant play, a towering kick. However, this appears to be a separate individual from Reece Walsh, whose performances are documented across several matches for the Broncos and Warriors. It is important to differentiate these players to avoid confusion when analyzing individual contributions.

Expert Perspectives on Walsh's Play

Commentary from rugby league analysts suggests Reece Walsh possesses significant talent. In May 2024, Greg Alexander described him as "terrific." Matty Johns suggested that if fit, Walsh should be considered for the halfback role in the NSW Blues team. This indicates a high regard for his abilities among those observing the game.

Conclusion: A Player of Contrasting Fortunes

The evidence indicates that Reece Walsh is a player of considerable skill, capable of producing "magic moments" and driving his team to victory, as seen in his try-scoring efforts for the Brisbane Broncos in July 2025. However, his career also shows instances of significant errors, most notably the costly kick-off in the April 2025 golden point loss to the Warriors, which led to a pivotal defeat. Coaching decisions, such as being benched by Stacey Jones in 2022, also form part of his journey. The emergence of another player, Joey Walsh, in a recent preseason game adds a layer of complexity to player identification but does not diminish the documented performances of Reece Walsh. His career trajectory thus far presents a narrative of both exceptional talent and the stark reality of crucial mistakes under pressure.

Read More: Bulldogs' Vegas Gamble: Are Extra Players a Costly Mistake or Genius Move?

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is Reece Walsh a good player?
Yes, Reece Walsh is seen as a very skilled player who can score tries and help his team win.
Q: Does Reece Walsh make mistakes?
Yes, sometimes Reece Walsh makes big mistakes, like a bad kick, that can help the other team win.
Q: Has Reece Walsh been benched before?
Yes, in 2022, he was benched by his coach for a game.
Q: Is Joey Walsh the same player as Reece Walsh?
No, Joey Walsh is a different player who played for Manly, not Reece Walsh.