Manchester City manager Pep Guardiola finds himself in a tangle of regulations as Marc Guehi, a recent acquisition, is barred from participating in the upcoming Carabao Cup final against Arsenal. The English Football League (EFL) rules stipulate that players signed after the first leg of the semi-final are ineligible for the remainder of the competition. This decision has ignited a storm of frustration from Guardiola, who has publicly decried the rule, questioning its logic and its impact on his team's preparations for the March 22nd Wembley showdown.
The crux of Guardiola's contention lies in the EFL's updated regulations this season, which, in principle, allow players to represent multiple clubs within the Carabao Cup. However, a specific deadline tied to the semi-final first leg has created this seemingly contradictory situation for Guehi. This update, intended to foster greater flexibility, has inadvertently ensnared a key City player. The manager has reportedly urged the club's hierarchy to appeal the decision, a plea that the EFL is expected to reject outright.
Read More: Arsenal Names Kepa in Goal for Carabao Cup Final vs Man City at Wembley
Guardiola’s dissatisfaction stems from what he perceives as an arbitrary barrier, particularly given the significant investment Manchester City has made in Guehi. "Because it's difficult to understand that the club who make a big investment to pay one player who belongs to us and I don't understand why he cannot play the final," he stated, articulating a sentiment of disbelief. This stance suggests a fundamental disagreement with the timing and application of the eligibility criteria, viewing it as an impediment to utilizing a player they now financially support.
Adding another layer to Guardiola's exasperation is the case of Antoine Semenyo, another January recruit. Semenyo, unlike Guehi, is eligible to play in the final. This disparity is attributed to the timing of his registration; Semenyo met the EFL's deadline, whereas Guehi's arrival occurred just past the crucial cut-off point. This detail highlights the fine print of the regulations and the stark difference in outcomes for players joining clubs mid-competition. Semenyo's own eligibility has courted controversy earlier in the season, having played in earlier rounds for his previous club, Bournemouth, before featuring for City in the semi-finals.
Read More: Richarlison Returns for Tottenham vs Nottingham Forest on March 15, 2026
The EFL's rule modification for the current season has indeed altered the landscape of player movement within the competition. Previously, a player who featured for one club in the Carabao Cup was 'cup-tied', meaning they could not play for another club in the same tournament. Guehi's situation is unique under these new rules, as he is the only player reportedly facing this specific type of ineligibility. The league's decision to maintain its stance, despite Guardiola's appeals, underscores a commitment to the established regulatory framework, even in the face of high-profile objections. The final is scheduled for 4:30 PM.
