The act of decluttering, often seen as a chore, is being reframed by several approaches that encourage a move away from emotional attachments to items. Instead of focusing on physical objects, these methods prompt individuals to examine the underlying reasons for keeping things, particularly those tied to future hopes or past investments. This investigation explores how the "ifs and buts" rule and similar strategies aim to simplify decision-making and reduce stress by emphasizing the present utility and genuine need for possessions.
The "Ifs and Buts" Rule: Deciphering Emotional Clutter
At the core of a new wave of decluttering advice is the "ifs and buts" rule, which challenges individuals to discard items that are kept due to hypothetical future scenarios or unfulfilled expectations. This method encourages a practical assessment, asking whether an item is genuinely used or missed, rather than justified by a potential, but unlikely, future need.
Read More: Best Items to Stay Dry When It Rains a Lot
Core Principle: Keep items that don't require negotiation or excuses for their presence.
Emotional Connection: Clutter often holds emotional weight, such as hope, guilt, or unfinished dreams, rather than being purely about physical objects.
Decision-Making: Acknowledging these deeper emotions can lead to more practical decisions about what to keep.
This approach suggests that our attachment to items is frequently driven by narratives we construct, such as owning a rarely used pizza oven or a dress with a style that is not actually preferred. The goal is to move towards a space filled with items that serve a clear purpose and are actively used, rather than those held onto out of obligation or sentimentality.
Trial Periods and Practical Application
Several decluttering strategies incorporate trial periods or practical tests to assess an item's true value. These methods aim to remove the guesswork and emotional debate often associated with letting go of possessions.
Read More: Doctor Shares Health Tips About Toilet Habits
The Six-Month Trial: Items are placed in a trial period. If they are not used or missed during this time, they are deemed unnecessary. This provides a concrete basis for decluttering decisions, particularly for wardrobes.
The 20/20 Rule: This rule suggests that if an item can be repurchased for less than $20 and within 20 minutes of need, it can likely be discarded. This removes the "just in case" mentality by acknowledging the ease of replacement.
The 90/90 Rule: This strategy focuses on recent and immediate future use. An item is kept only if it has been used in the last 90 days and is expected to be used in the next 90 days. This rule is particularly effective for eliminating items held onto due to potential future use that is unlikely to materialize.
These trial-based approaches provide objective criteria for decision-making, moving beyond subjective feelings about an item's potential or past value.
Beyond "Ifs and Buts": Complementary Decluttering Strategies
While the "ifs and buts" rule addresses the emotional and hypothetical reasons for keeping items, other strategies offer practical frameworks for physical decluttering and maintaining order. These methods focus on actionable steps and the establishment of routines.
Read More: Many Olympic Athletes Have Regular Jobs to Support Their Dreams
The One-in-One-Out Rule: This simple principle dictates that for every new item brought into the home, a similar item must be removed. This proactive approach helps prevent clutter accumulation.
The Rule of 5: This method encourages the removal of five items each time one enters a room. It's a small, consistent effort designed to make a visible impact over time.
Organizing Principles: Keeping items visible and storing them near their point of use are recommended for practical organization. Giving every item a designated "home" also streamlines the process of putting things away.
These diverse methods, ranging from psychological insights to simple routines, aim to make the process of decluttering less stressful and more effective.
Expert Analysis: The Psychology of Clutter and Letting Go
Decluttering is increasingly recognized as having significant mental health benefits. Experts suggest that clutter can impact stress levels and overall well-being, and the process of clearing it can act as a form of behavioral activation.
"Clutter doesn’t necessarily reflect messy habits. Our clutter is often carrying emotional meaning — hope, guilt, optimism or unfinished dreams — not just physical belongings." - HuffPost
The emphasis on understanding the emotional roots of clutter, as highlighted by the "ifs and buts" rule, is seen as a key to successful decluttering. By addressing the psychological aspects, individuals can make more rational decisions about their possessions.
"The 20/20 rule takes away the emotional debate, it makes the hard calls for you. After using the 20/20 method, I realised decluttering doesn’t have to feel like a battle of logic versus sentiment." - Good Housekeeping UK
This perspective suggests that practical rules can serve as valuable tools to overcome the sentimental barriers that often impede decluttering efforts.
Conclusion: A Practical Shift in Perspective
The analyzed information indicates a convergence of decluttering strategies towards practical application and a reduced emphasis on emotional attachment to possessions. The "ifs and buts" rule, along with methods like the 20/20 and 90/90 rules, provide frameworks for objective decision-making, encouraging the retention of items based on current utility rather than hypothetical future use or past sentiment. Complementary rules such as "one-in-one-out" and the "rule of five" offer practical mechanisms for preventing future clutter. Experts confirm the psychological benefits of decluttering, suggesting that understanding the emotional underpinnings of clutter is crucial for successful and less stressful clearing. These approaches collectively aim to simplify the decluttering process by shifting the focus from the act of discarding to a more mindful assessment of an item's true role in one's life.
Sources:
HuffPost: "This 1 Rule Will Help You Declutter And Clean Your Home Immediately" - https://www.huffpost.com/entry/ifs-and-buts-rule-declutteringl69728e27e4b00114c521c335
Context: This article introduces the "ifs and buts" rule, explaining its psychological underpinnings related to emotional attachments to possessions and its role in making practical decluttering decisions.
Tomsguide: "Experts recommend the 'ifs and buts' rule to declutter your wardrobe this summer — here's how it works" - https://www.tomsguide.com/home/experts-recommend-the-ifs-and-buts-rule-to-declutter-your-wardrobe-this-summer-heres-how-it-works
Context: This article focuses on the application of the "ifs and buts" rule specifically to wardrobe decluttering, suggesting a trial period as a method for determining an item's usefulness.
Honey Nine: "Two words to ask yourself to make decluttering clothes easier" - https://honey.nine.com.au/living/decluttering-idea-ifs-and-buts-rule-explained/56384f2e-b670-4281-9f2b-833f336c15ee
Context: This piece discusses the simplicity of the "ifs and buts" approach for decluttering clothes, touching upon hesitation in decision-making.
The Uncluttered Life: "Master the 20/20 Rule for Decluttering | Uncluttered Life" - https://www.theunclutteredlife.com/blog/what-is-the-20-20-rule-for-decluttering
Context: This article details the 20/20 decluttering rule, which provides a financial and time-based criterion for deciding whether to keep or discard an item.
Be More With Less: "10 Decluttering Rules That Make Letting Go So Much Easier" - https://bemorewithless.com/decluttering-101/
Context: This article presents a collection of decluttering rules, emphasizing the importance of simplifying life and letting go for personal well-being rather than out of guilt or fear.
Columbia Doctors: "Reduce Stress through Decluttering" - https://www.columbiadoctors.org/news/reduce-stress-through-decluttering
Context: This source explores the mental health benefits of decluttering and its role in stress reduction, framing it as a beneficial activity for psychological well-being.
Modern Minimalism: "10 Rules for Organizing That Work in Every Room" - https://modernminimalism.com/rules-for-organizing/
Context: This article offers practical organization tips, including the benefit of visibility and storing items near their usage points, as well as assigning a "home" for each item.
Kalyn Brooke: "The One Decluttering Rule You Have Probably Never Heard Of" - https://kalynbrooke.com/stress-less-living/how-to-start-decluttering-when-overwhelmed/
Context: This piece discusses the "One-in-One-Out" rule as a method to maintain a decluttered state after the initial process.
Good Housekeeping UK: "The 20/20 declutter method is the secret to getting rid of those things you're holding onto 'just in case'" - https://www.goodhousekeeping.com/uk/house-and-home/household-advice/a69263429/20-20-decluttering-method/
Context: This article provides a personal account and explanation of the 20/20 decluttering method, highlighting its effectiveness in removing emotional debates.
A Tozen Life: "20 Decluttering Rules the Experts Say Are "Life-Changing"" - https://atozenlife.com/rules-for-decluttering/
Context: This source lists various decluttering rules, suggesting they can simplify life and inspire action for those feeling stuck or overwhelmed.
Be More With Less: "Start Decluttering With This One Simple Rule" - https://bemorewithless.com/start-decluttering/
Context: This article emphasizes starting decluttering by focusing on what one loves, which aids in releasing unwanted items and discovering enjoyment beneath the clutter.
Scarlet State: "Rule of 5 Decluttering: The Fast Track to an Organized Home" - https://scarletstate.co.uk/rule-of-5-decluttering-the-fast-track-to-an-organized-home
Context: This article explains the "Rule of 5," a simple method of removing five items from a room each time one enters it, for consistent clutter reduction.
The Simplicity Habit: "5 Golden Rules of Decluttering (to Save You Time, Effort, and Energy)" - https://www.thesimplicityhabit.com/5-golden-rules-of-decluttering/
Context: This piece presents five key decluttering rules aimed at saving time, effort, and energy, and prompts reflection on what is kept and discarded.
Homes & Gardens: "8 Psychology-Backed Tips to Calm Your Nervous System While Decluttering Successfully in 2026" - https://www.homesandgardens.com/solved/how-to-calm-your-nervous-system-while-decluttering
Context: This article offers psychological tips for managing stress during decluttering, focusing on regulating the nervous system and using methods like dopamine pairing.
Good Housekeeping: "The Best Way to Declutter Fast? Try the 90/90 Rule" - https://www.goodhousekeeping.com/home/organizing/a70025689/before-you-declutter-i-tried-90-90-rule/
Context: This article explains and provides a personal review of the 90/90 decluttering rule, which involves discarding items not used in the last 90 days and not expected to be used in the next 90.
Shafaqna: "The 'Ifs And Buts' Rule Takes The Stress Out Of Decluttering" - https://canada.shafaqna.com/EN/AL/2801252
Context: This source is listed but its content was too short or failed to extract, potentially reinforcing the "ifs and buts" rule's stress-reducing potential.
Scarlet State: "The Secret to Successful Decluttering: Embrace the First Rule" - https://scarletstate.co.uk/the-secret-to-successful-decluttering-embrace-the-first-rule
Context: Similar to the previous source, this article was noted with short or failed extraction, possibly referencing a foundational decluttering principle.
