Decision Marks End of an Era for Fourth Overall Pick
The Indianapolis Colts have officially declined the fifth-year option on quarterback Anthony Richardson Sr.'s rookie contract. This move effectively ends Richardson's tenure with the Colts beyond the 2026 season, as he is now slated to become an unrestricted free agent. The decision, made before the May 1 deadline, signals a decisive shift in the team's quarterback strategy, moving away from a prolonged period of waiting for Richardson's potential to materialize.
Sources indicate that the Colts have already begun rebuilding their quarterback situation around a different model of stability. This departure from exercising the option on a first-round pick suggests the franchise has been contemplating a new direction for some time. Richardson, who has struggled with both performance and injuries during his short stint with the team, has not attended voluntary offseason workouts.
Read More: Blue Jays Beat Twins 9-8 After Big Comeback on August 27, 2025
Richardson's Colts Career Marked by Uncertainty
Anthony Richardson has faced significant hurdles since being drafted fourth overall in 2023. His time in Indianapolis has been characterized by inconsistent play and recurring injuries, including a severe AC joint sprain in his throwing shoulder that required surgery. Despite flashes of talent and athleticism, his ability to consistently impact games has been hampered by these disruptions.
Adding to the complexity, Richardson himself has reportedly requested a trade from the Colts and was granted permission to speak with other teams. This request further underscores the growing distance between the player and the organization. The team's commitment to Daniel Jones, who was acquired last offseason and signed to a significant contract, further solidifies the perception that the Colts are moving forward with a different vision at the quarterback position.
Background on the Decision
The Colts' decision not to exercise Richardson's fifth-year option was largely anticipated. General manager Chris Ballard has acknowledged that other teams have shown limited interest in trading for the young quarterback. This lack of a robust trade market highlights how Richardson is currently viewed within the league.
Read More: Colts Won't Keep Quarterback Richardson After 2026 Season
In the immediate future, Richardson is understood to be competing with Riley Leonard for a backup role behind Daniel Jones. The lack of a definitive starting role and the team's investment in Jones have made the contract decision a near formality. The Colts are now faced with determining Richardson's status for the remainder of his contract, with potential trade scenarios or a release if a trade partner cannot be found. Former NFL player Devin McCourty has offered advice to Richardson, urging him to focus on development and learning, regardless of his immediate situation.
