Colts Won't Keep Quarterback Richardson After 2026 Season

The Colts will not extend Anthony Richardson's contract beyond the 2026 season. This means he will become a free agent, unlike other top draft picks.

Indianapolis – The Indianapolis Colts have opted not to exercise the fifth-year option on quarterback Anthony Richardson's contract, a move widely anticipated given the player's tumultuous tenure. This decision effectively positions Richardson for unrestricted free agency following the 2026 season, introducing significant uncertainty about his future with the club.

Richardson, who was selected as the fourth overall pick, has faced a challenging start to his NFL career. His rookie season was truncated by a shoulder injury requiring surgery. Reports indicate he has not participated in voluntary offseason workouts and previously requested a trade, though General Manager Chris Ballard has publicly acknowledged the possibility of Richardson remaining with the team.

Sources confirm the Colts' decision, first reported by Fox59 in Indianapolis. The financial implications of the fifth-year option, described as a "major investment," were apparently a key factor, especially considering Richardson has not solidified his role as a consistent starter. He has reportedly been competing for a backup position with Riley Leonard.

Read More: Toronto Raptors Force Game 7 vs Cleveland Cavaliers

The lack of a clear starting role and the player's trade request appear to have made the option decision a foregone conclusion. The team is reportedly focused on finding a trade partner to ensure a "fair return" for Richardson, with the understanding that a swift resolution benefits all parties. The NFL's deadline for exercising such options passed on May 1, 2026.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Why did the Indianapolis Colts decline Anthony Richardson's fifth-year contract option?
The Colts decided not to pick up the option because of Richardson's injury history and his lack of a solidified starting role. The cost of the option was also a factor.
Q: What happens to Anthony Richardson's contract with the Colts?
The Colts will not extend his contract beyond the 2026 season. This means he will become an unrestricted free agent after the 2026 season.
Q: Will the Colts try to trade Anthony Richardson before he becomes a free agent?
The team is reportedly looking for a trade partner to get a fair return for Richardson before he can leave as a free agent.
Q: When did the Colts have to make this decision?
The deadline for NFL teams to exercise these contract options was May 1, 2026.