Bachelorette Season Cancelled After Taylor Frankie Paul Controversy

The new Bachelorette season starring Taylor Frankie Paul has been cancelled by ABC. This is the first time a whole season was pulled due to controversy.
By Newsroom | Television, Entertainment |

ABC/Disney has abruptly pulled the plug on the upcoming season of "The Bachelorette," starring Taylor Frankie Paul, a decision that has sent ripples through the franchise and its associated brands. The cancellation follows a barrage of resurfaced violence allegations, concerning footage, and dueling public statements between Paul and her ex-boyfriend, Dakota Mortensen, with whom she shares a son. The network's gamble to inject new life into a flagging franchise by casting a controversial social media personality has backfired spectacularly.

The Bachelorette's messy break-up with its unlikely star Taylor Frankie Paul - 1

The fallout has been swift and far-reaching. Cinnabon, a key promotional partner, has terminated its collaboration with "The Bachelorette" and Paul's reality show, "The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives" (SLOMW), citing a misalignment with brand values. Furthermore, Paul's scheduled appearance on "The Tonight Show" has been canceled. Production on season five of SLOMW has also been put on indefinite pause.

Read More: HBO's The Last of Us Season 3 Adds Yara and Lev Actors Michelle Mao and Kyriana Kratter

The Bachelorette's messy break-up with its unlikely star Taylor Frankie Paul - 2

A Risky Casting Gambit Unravels

Paul, who gained prominence through Hulu's SLOMW and her "#MomTok" presence on TikTok, was apparently chosen to anchor the new season of "The Bachelorette" with the explicit aim of leveraging her substantial social media following. This strategy, coupled with cross-promotional efforts involving Hulu, appears to have been a calculated risk by ABC/Disney to revitalize the venerable dating show.

The Bachelorette's messy break-up with its unlikely star Taylor Frankie Paul - 3

"The network’s cross-promotion with Hulu and capitalizing on Paul’s large social audience backfired when resurfaced violence allegations and related footage emerged."

Sources suggest that the extent of Paul's tumultuous past – including a criminal conviction, documented alcohol use, and reported mental health struggles – was either overlooked or deemed a manageable risk. However, as industry commentator Hemmings noted, these issues ultimately rendered her "not worth the risk to cast."

The Bachelorette's messy break-up with its unlikely star Taylor Frankie Paul - 4

Escalating Allegations and Brand Pushback

The situation intensified with the emergence of competing statements from Paul and her ex-boyfriend, Dakota Mortensen. These statements included "fresh allegations" concerning their "turbulent relationship," further complicating the narrative. A protective order was reportedly granted, giving temporary custody of their son to Mortensen, adding a legal dimension to the unfolding drama.

Read More: Bachelorette Season Cancelled: Contestants May Sue ABC and Warner Bros.

"Disney and ABC made a bet that Paul’s tumultuous past would either blow over or be worth the attention boost to its flagging franchise, and that her instability would attract viewers rather than repel them."

This particular season of "The Bachelorette" was reportedly entirely filmed and poised for a Sunday premiere, making the abrupt cancellation all the more significant. The decision signifies a profound reassessment of the network's casting strategy and its tolerance for associated reputational damage.

Background: The "Mormon Wives" Phenomenon and Influencer Culture

Taylor Frankie Paul's journey to "The Bachelorette" is intrinsically linked to her role in "The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives," a documentary-style series that chronicled her life and that of her social circle. Her pregnancy announcement in September seemingly occurred amidst this continued turbulence.

The casting choice highlights a broader trend of legacy media outlets seeking to tap into the raw, often contentious, appeal of social media influencers to capture younger audiences or revive aging franchises. Critics argue that this approach frequently leads to overlooking or minimizing "red flags" in pursuit of "influencer clout," a practice seemingly exemplified by this "debacle," which is reportedly poised to cost ABC tens of millions of dollars.

Read More: Guy Ritchie's New Movie 'Operation: Fortune' Fails to Start Franchise

Notably, unlike typical "Bachelorette" contestants, Paul was permitted to retain her phone during production. This exception was reportedly made to facilitate communication with her three young children and to allow her to share behind-the-scenes content, a detail that underscores the unique circumstances surrounding her casting.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Why did ABC cancel the new Bachelorette season starring Taylor Frankie Paul?
ABC cancelled the season because of old claims of violence and videos involving Taylor Frankie Paul. This happened after she was chosen to be the Bachelorette.
Q: What other brands or shows are affected by this cancellation?
Cinnabon stopped its deal with 'The Bachelorette' and Paul's show 'The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives'. Also, Paul's visit to 'The Tonight Show' is cancelled and filming for season five of 'Mormon Wives' is paused.
Q: Why was Taylor Frankie Paul chosen for The Bachelorette?
She was chosen to help ABC's dating show get more viewers. They wanted to use her big following on social media, especially TikTok, to make the show popular again.
Q: What problems did Taylor Frankie Paul have before?
There were claims about her past relationship with her ex-boyfriend, Dakota Mortensen. There were also reports of criminal charges, drinking alcohol, and mental health issues.
Q: What happened with Taylor Frankie Paul's son?
A court order was given that temporarily gave custody of their son to Dakota Mortensen. This was because of new claims about their difficult relationship.
Q: Was the new Bachelorette season already filmed?
Yes, the season was reportedly already filmed and was going to start soon. The cancellation means ABC is rethinking how they choose people for their shows.