Zach Merrett, the captain of Essendon, is once again contemplating his AFL future, with persistent speculation suggesting he might seek a trade at the conclusion of the current season. This comes after a failed attempt to move to Hawthorn in the previous year. Rival clubs reportedly see the Bombers' significant salary cap space and the team's potential for premiership success as a compelling draw, should Merrett opt to depart.
Merrett's commitment to Essendon appears uncertain, marked by his weighing up of options and acknowledged frustration, fueling speculation of an impending trade request.
Despite being contracted for another two years and holding the captaincy, Merrett is understood to be disgruntled at Essendon after 12 seasons. This sentiment was reportedly communicated after his discussions with Hawthorn figures, including coach Sam Mitchell. The club's board of directors has, however, maintained a firm stance, unanimously agreeing that Merrett would not be traded.
Read More: Melbourne Demons Encourage Risk-Taking As Season Gets Tougher
Lingering Questions and Past Efforts
The uncertainty surrounding Merrett's tenure at Tullamarine has been a recurring theme. His interest in a move away from the Bombers was public knowledge following a meeting with Hawthorn officials. Merrett himself acknowledged that multiple factors contributed to his consideration of a move, stating, "We'll see what happens in the next few weeks." He also commented on the difficulty of his position as an out-of-contract player seeking opportunities.
Club's Stance and Player's Actions
Essendon's president, Andrew Welsh, has publicly stated that the club has incorporated Merrett's suggestions following the failed trade attempt and continues to back coach Brad Scott. However, the club's position has also been that Merrett would not be traded, with the board reportedly deciding he would remain at Essendon under any circumstances.
"Merrett could yet be held to his contract, despite his apparent farewell speech after winning his sixth Crichton Medal."
This was evident in Merrett's acceptance speech after winning Essendon's best and fairest award, where he alluded to the possibility of his departure. His management and the club were contacted for comment regarding the ongoing speculation.
Read More: Latrell Mitchell out of Origin 1 due to back injury
Background of Discontent
The current situation echoes a similar period of introspection for Merrett approximately 12 months prior. During that time, his potential departure was widely discussed, with Hawthorn and Melbourne both showing interest. Despite a public declaration from Essendon that Merrett would play out his contract and hopefully beyond, the persistent rumours indicate a level of unresolved frustration.
"He understands the frustration, there’s no doubt these two players are frustrated."
This frustration is also noted in relation to other players, suggesting a broader team sentiment. Merrett's form throughout the 2025 season, even amidst a challenging campaign for Essendon, was notable, averaging 27.8 disposals, 5.3 inside 50s, and 3.9 clearances per game.
Ultimately, Merrett stepped down as club captain in November 2025 following the unsuccessful trade saga, an act described by the club as a "selfless leader prioritising the best interests of the club". He has since returned to pre-season training with Essendon.
Read More: Scott Pendlebury's 433rd game: Gold jersey sparks fan anger
