A central figure in the upcoming series, Ser Duncan the Tall, also known as Dunk, is presented as a knight. However, a notable fan theory, supported by subtle clues in George R.R. Martin's writings and the television adaptation, suggests that Dunk may have never been formally knighted. This discrepancy raises questions about his legitimacy and the nature of his title.
Origins of the Discrepancy
The narrative of Dunk and Egg originates from a series of novellas by George R.R. Martin. The primary source of speculation about Dunk's knighthood appears to stem from his mentor, Ser Arlan of Pennytree.
In the novellas, Dunk himself often makes statements about being knighted by Ser Arlan.
These references are frequently accompanied by Dunk looking away or down, which some interpret as a sign of deception or discomfort.
The story suggests that Ser Arlan died before he could officially knight Dunk.
Therefore, Dunk's subsequent actions and claims to knighthood may have been based on necessity rather than formal investiture.
Evidence Presented
Multiple sources point to specific instances and narrative devices that fuel the theory of Dunk's unknighted status.
Hesitation to Knight Others: In "A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms" episode 4, Raymun Fossoway, a squire, requests knighthood before a battle. Dunk hesitates, and Ser Lyonel Baratheon ultimately performs the knighting. This hesitation is seen as a significant indicator that Dunk feels unqualified to knight another.
Subtle Storytelling: Martin has reportedly used indirect methods to hint at Dunk's true status. A particular scene depicts Ser Arlan recounting a familiar story to Dunk. Later, upon learning of Egg's true identity as a prince, Dunk experiences a moment of realization, leading to a situation where another knight knighted Raymun instead.
Dunk's Own Actions: Following Ser Arlan's death, Dunk is shown contemplating finding another knight to squire for. This action, it is argued, would be illogical if Dunk himself had recently been knighted.
Visual Cues in Adaptations: The television series, "A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms," has added visual elements that seem to support the theory. These include Dunk's reactions and expressions when his knighthood is mentioned.
Conflicting Interpretations and Showrunner Input
While the evidence suggests Dunk may not be a formally recognized knight, some interpretations offer alternative perspectives.
Read More: 2026 Winter Olympics Funny Posts Make People Laugh More Than Watch
The Nature of Knighthood: It is posited that knighthood can be conferred by any knight, and Dunk's own skills and experiences might make him functionally a knight, regardless of the formal ceremony.
Showrunner's Perspective: The showrunner has indicated that the series will explore Dunk's character and his actions will define him as a knight, even if the formal investiture is in question. This suggests a focus on the spirit of knighthood over its procedural attainment.
Character Development: The possibility of Dunk being unknighted is viewed by some as a more compelling narrative element, making him a more complex and interesting hero who embodies the ideals of a knight through his actions.
Conclusion and Unresolved Questions
The available information strongly suggests that Ser Duncan the Tall may have never undergone the formal ceremony of knighting. The evidence, including his own behaviors, narrative hints, and character interactions within the stories, creates a compelling case for this theory.
The core of the argument rests on Ser Arlan's death prior to officially knighting Dunk.
Dunk's subsequent actions and the portrayal of his reactions to situations involving knighthood are interpreted as indicators of his lack of formal status.
The television adaptation appears to be leaning into this mystery, potentially exploring the theme of what truly constitutes a knight.
However, the definitive answer regarding Dunk's formal knighthood remains subject to interpretation and the unfolding narrative of "A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms." Whether he was officially knighted or not, his legend appears to be built on his deeds rather than the singular act of investiture.
Polygon: https://www.polygon.com/is-dunk-a-knight-in-seven-kingdoms-explainer/
ScreenRant: https://screenrant.com/a-knight-of-the-seven-kingdoms-dunk-knighthood-explained/
Inverse: https://www.inverse.com/entertainment/knight-of-the-seven-kingdoms-theory-dunk-knight
Gamerant: https://gamerant.com/game-of-thrones-akotsk-dunk-not-a-knight-theory/
Collider: https://collider.com/a-knight-of-the-seven-kingdoms-dunk-character-mystery-knighthood/
Winter is Coming: https://winteriscoming.net/did-ser-arlan-of-pennytree-actually-knight-dunk-a-knight-of-the-seven-kingdoms-showrunner-weighs-in
CBR: https://www.cbr.com/game-of-thrones-knight-of-seven-kingdoms-ser-duncan-hedge-knight-title-explained/
)