Piers Morgan says Prince Andrew still in royal line of succession is 'preposterous' for UK monarchy

Piers Morgan strongly criticizes Prince Andrew's continued place in the royal line of succession, calling it 'preposterous' and a threat to the monarchy.
By Newsroom | Royal Family, United Kingdom |

A recent development has drawn sharp commentary from media personality Piers Morgan, who has voiced strong objections to Prince Andrew's continued presence in the line of succession for the British throne. This stance follows Prince Andrew's arrest and subsequent removal of royal titles by King Charles, incidents that have reportedly caused a significant rift within the monarchy. Morgan's remarks highlight a perceived contradiction: the Duke of York being stripped of his royal status and residence while still maintaining a place in the direct line of succession, a situation he has described as "preposterous" and a major threat to the institution's future.

Piers Morgan Slams 'Preposterous' Reality of Andrew Remaining in Succession Line Following Shock Birthday Arrest - 1

Background of the Controversy

The situation surrounding Prince Andrew has unfolded over several years, marked by allegations related to his association with convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein. These allegations led to significant public pressure and a formal investigation.

Read More: Prince Andrew Released Under Investigation After Misconduct Arrest in Norfolk

Piers Morgan Slams 'Preposterous' Reality of Andrew Remaining in Succession Line Following Shock Birthday Arrest - 2

  • Allegations and Legal Proceedings: Prince Andrew faced accusations from Virginia Giuffre, a victim of Epstein, who claimed she was sexually abused by the Duke. While Andrew has denied these claims, a lawsuit was filed against him.

  • Loss of Titles and Residence: In a decisive action, King Charles formally stripped Prince Andrew of his royal titles, including Duke of York, and removed him from the Royal Lodge, his official residence. He is now reportedly known as Andrew Mountbatten Windsor and is expected to reside on the Sandringham Estate. This move signifies a demotion from his previous royal standing.

  • Sarah Ferguson's Defense: Prince Andrew's ex-wife, Sarah Ferguson, has publicly stated her support for him, vowing not to abandon him amidst the ongoing controversy.

  • Government Stance on Succession: Despite the removal of his titles, government officials have indicated there are no current plans to alter Prince Andrew's position as eighth in line to the throne. This requires no new legislation.

Piers Morgan's Statements

Piers Morgan has been vocal in his criticism of Prince Andrew's situation, particularly concerning his continued place in the line of succession.

Piers Morgan Slams 'Preposterous' Reality of Andrew Remaining in Succession Line Following Shock Birthday Arrest - 3

  • "Preposterous" Succession: Morgan has described the reality of Prince Andrew remaining in the line of succession after losing his titles and public role as "preposterous." He expressed this sentiment during a discussion on Fox & Friends, where the hosts were reportedly taken aback by the situation.

  • Threat to Monarchy: He has warned that the ongoing scandal and its handling pose a significant threat to the future of the monarchy, calling it an "absolute bombshell."

  • Reaction to Title Removal: Morgan reacted to the King's decision to remove Andrew's titles with the concise statement, "De-Princed. Astonishing." This reflects his view on the gravity of the King's actions.

Analysis of the Succession Issue

The question of Prince Andrew's position in the line of succession, despite his disassociation from royal duties and titles, raises a fundamental query about the rules governing royal succession.

Piers Morgan Slams 'Preposterous' Reality of Andrew Remaining in Succession Line Following Shock Birthday Arrest - 4

  • Current Legal Framework: The line of succession is primarily governed by the Bill of Rights 1689 and the Act of Settlement 1701. These historical documents do not automatically exclude individuals based on personal conduct or loss of titles, provided they meet the criteria of being a legitimate descendant and adhere to religious requirements.

  • No Immediate Change: Government statements confirm that no legislative action is planned to remove Prince Andrew from his place in the succession. This implies that any alteration would require a formal act of Parliament.

  • Public and Royal Reaction: While Prince Andrew has been removed from royal life, his position in the succession remains unchanged. This duality has been a point of contention for critics like Piers Morgan.

Expert and Media Commentary

Commentators have widely discussed the implications of Prince Andrew's diminished royal status and his continued position in the succession line.

  • "Historic Crisis": Some media outlets have characterized the situation as an "historic crisis" for the monarchy, emphasizing the unprecedented nature of a senior royal being stripped of titles and facing such public scrutiny.

  • Constitutional Anomaly: The perceived disconnect between Prince Andrew's public disgrace and his hereditary claim has been noted as a constitutional anomaly, leaving observers questioning the logic of the current arrangement.

  • "Rock Bottom": Reports have speculated whether this represents "rock bottom" for Prince Andrew, particularly as he becomes dependent on the King for his financial support and housing.

Conclusion

Piers Morgan's strong opposition to Prince Andrew's continued presence in the royal line of succession highlights a significant public and media debate. While Prince Andrew has been divested of his royal titles and responsibilities, the legal framework governing the monarchy's succession does not appear to facilitate his removal from that line without further parliamentary action. This enduring position, despite his public discrediting, has been labeled "preposterous" by Morgan and has contributed to broader discussions about the monarchy's stability and public perception in the face of scandal. The government's stated intention not to alter the succession law suggests that this situation is likely to persist unless further developments necessitate legislative intervention.

Read More: Prince Andrew Arrested for Misconduct in Public Office on 66th Birthday

Sources Used:

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Why does Piers Morgan think Prince Andrew staying in the royal line of succession is 'preposterous'?
Piers Morgan believes it is 'preposterous' that Prince Andrew still holds a place in the royal line of succession. This is because Prince Andrew has been stripped of his royal titles and removed from royal duties by King Charles, making his continued position in line for the throne seem contradictory and a threat to the monarchy's image.
Q: What happened to Prince Andrew's royal titles and residence?
King Charles has removed Prince Andrew's royal titles, including Duke of York. He was also removed from his official residence, the Royal Lodge. He is now reportedly known as Andrew Mountbatten Windsor and may live on the Sandringham Estate.
Q: Will Prince Andrew be removed from the line of succession to the British throne?
Currently, there are no plans to remove Prince Andrew from the line of succession. Government officials have stated that changing his position would require new laws passed by Parliament, and no such action is planned at this time.
Q: Why can Prince Andrew remain in the line of succession even after losing his titles?
The rules for royal succession, based on old laws like the Bill of Rights 1689 and the Act of Settlement 1701, do not automatically remove someone from the line of succession just because they lose their titles or public roles. To change this, Parliament would need to pass new laws.
Q: Who is affected by Prince Andrew's situation and his place in the royal line of succession?
The British monarchy as an institution is affected, as its public image and stability are questioned. Also, people interested in the royal family and the future of the throne are affected, as this situation raises concerns about how scandals are handled and how the line of succession works.