Defenseman Left Out of Top Three Finalists
The NHL has unveiled its finalists for the Norris Trophy, sparking considerable discussion with the exclusion of Montreal Canadiens defenseman Lane Hutson. The league confirmed on May 7, 2026, that Rasmus Dahlin, Cale Makar, and Zach Werenski are the three contenders for the award recognizing the NHL's top defenseman.
Hutson, a young player who has demonstrated a significant impact on the Canadiens' transition game, posted 78 points this past season. This offensive output surpassed Dahlin's 74 points, a fact that has amplified the debate surrounding Hutson's absence from the finalist group. Some observers noted that Dahlin was not among the top five in points for defensemen, adding another layer to the controversy.
While acknowledging Hutson will likely have future opportunities to contend for the Norris, many commentators expressed surprise, especially considering his performance. This marks a notable departure from expectations, as some had anticipated Hutson to be at least close to the podium in the voting.
Read More: England May Debut Sonny Baker If Weather Allows vs New Zealand
Analysis and Reactions
"Much of the reaction centered around the omission of Edmonton Oilers defenseman Evan Bouchard and Montreal Canadiens‘ youngster Lane Hutson."
The decision to exclude Hutson has generated significant commentary across sports media. Reporters like Elliotte Friedman have admitted that Hutson did not make his personal top five ballot for the award this year, a candid admission that has further fueled the conversation. Friedman's perspective suggests that while Hutson's talent is evident, his inclusion among the very top candidates this season was not universally recognized by voters.
Some writers had placed Hutson within their top five, even noting he received more votes than Dahlin from certain ballots. For instance, one report from April 21, 2026, indicated Hutson was ranked third in votes received, behind only Werenski and Makar. This discrepancy between his actual ballot placements and the official finalist list highlights a division in how his season was perceived.
Background
Lane Hutson, at just 22 years old, has rapidly built a resume that suggests future accolades are likely. His collegiate career was marked by significant individual honors, including Hockey East Rookie of the Year and Hockey East Scoring Champion. He was also named a unanimous selection to the All-Hockey East First Team and All-Hockey East Rookie Team.
Read More: Marner's Media Day Focuses on Off-Ice Topics, Not Stanley Cup
Internationally, Hutson has represented the United States in multiple tournaments, earning silver medals at the U18 World Championships twice and a gold medal at the 2024 World Junior Championships, where he was recognized as the tournament's top defenseman. He also holds dual citizenship, being a citizen of both Canada and the United States. His older brothers, Quinn and Cole, also play professional hockey, with Quinn drafted by the Edmonton Oilers and Cole a defenseman for the Washington Capitals.
