Public records and official statements from late 2024 through late 2025 show a pattern of conflicting information regarding the career path of Nick Daicos. While some reports claimed the star player had "officially" decided to leave the Collingwood Football Club, later statements from the player himself indicate a firm commitment to staying. This investigation looks at the timeline of these events, the physical condition of the team, and the financial offers made by rival clubs.
"I grew up with black and white in my veins. I love this club, this jumper, and these fans. There was never any real thought of leaving." — Nick Daicos, July 2025.
Collingwood faced heavy scrutiny in early 2025 for having an older roster, yet Daicos ended the year by publicly rejecting all trade offers to remain with the team.
Timeline of Key Events
| Date | Event | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Nov 30, 2024 | Report of departure to Sydney Swans. | Contradicted by later appearances. |
| Mar 9, 2025 | Collingwood loses to GWS. | Critics call the team "old and slow." |
| Apr 27, 2025 | Report of "Major Announcement" to leave. | Details remained unverified. |
| Jul 10, 2025 | Rejected Tasmania Devils offer. | Daicos stays to "finish what he started." |
| Oct 11, 2025 | Final trade shut down. | Daicos confirms he is staying at Collingwood. |
Team Fitness and Early Season Pressure
In March 2025, the physical state of the Collingwood roster became a point of public debate. Following a defeat against the GWS Giants, observers noted that the team appeared unprepared for the speed of the game.
Read More: Gold Coast Suns and St Kilda Saints pre-season game shows new players but raises contract questions
The team had an average age of 28 years and three months.
Kane Cornes, a sports commentator, stated that the team was "exposed" when the ball moved into open space.
Nick Daicos suffered from cramps during the game, leading to questions about his fitness levels.
Coach Craig McRae dismissed these concerns, attributing the issues to minor physical stress rather than a lack of preparation.
Contradictory Reports on Player Movement
There is a clear gap between media reports and the player’s actual actions. In late 2024 and early 2025, multiple sources claimed Daicos was leaving the club. However, he remained on the roster and continued to play for the Magpies throughout the 2025 season.
"Sydney’s gain is our loss." — Reported quote attributed to Craig McRae in November 2024 regarding a move that did not happen.
The records show that on April 27, 2025, another report suggested a departure was finalized. Despite this, by July 2025, Daicos was publicly discussing his long-term legacy with Collingwood. This raises the question: were these early reports based on actual negotiations that failed, or were they inaccurate representations of the player's intentions?
Financial Offers and Family Legacy
The expansion of the AFL to include the Tasmania Devils introduced significant financial pressure. In July 2025, reports emerged that Daicos turned down a contract worth $5 million to join the new team.
Legacy Ties: As the son of Tony Daicos, Nick cited family history as a primary reason for staying.
Leadership Role: Despite his young age, he began working with older players to take on more responsibility within the club.
Tasmania's Status: Daicos noted that the Tasmania team was still "a little while away" from being ready, which influenced his decision to stay in a stable environment.
The Final Rejection of Trade Rumors
In October 2025, just before the trade deadline, Daicos spoke at the Caulfield racecourse to end all speculation. He stated clearly that he would not be "prised away" by rival sides.
Read More: Canada Curling Team Loses to Norway 8-6 and Faces Them Again in Olympic Semifinal
He confirmed that his manager, Robbie, had not brought any "serious" offers to his attention that would require him to leave.
He expressed support for Collingwood potentially hiring new players, such as Jy Simpkin, rather than leaving himself.
He emphasized that he is "fully committed" and wants to "put to bed" any ideas of him wearing another team's colors.
Expert Analysis
Kane Cornes, AFL Commentator:"The Giants exposed them when the ball got outside the contest. They didn't look prepared. While Daicos is a star, the team's average age of over 28 is a major concern for their longevity."
Craig McRae, Collingwood Head Coach:"Nick's leadership and work ethic are exceptional. We don't sweat on the small things like cramps; he is a key part of our future."
Nick Daicos, Collingwood Player:"I keep putting my effort and energy into the Collingwood football club. If it’s anything serious… I’ll let you know. I haven’t let [the fans] know as of yet."
Conclusion of Investigation
The evidence shows that while Collingwood faced challenges regarding the age and speed of their players in early 2025, the rumors of Nick Daicos leaving the club were not supported by his final actions. Reports in November 2024 and April 2025 claiming he had "officially" left for the Sydney Swans or other clubs were followed by Daicos continuing to play and lead at Collingwood.
The investigation finds that the player chose the stability of his family legacy over a high-value $5 million offer from Tasmania. By October 2025, the matter was settled by the player's own public statements. The next steps for the club involve managing their aging roster while integrating the young leadership Daicos provides.
Primary Sources
Extraordinary Nick Daicos sight masks major Collingwood concern - Analysis of team age and fitness on March 9, 2025.
Pies superstar responds to bombshell trade reports - Official trade denial from October 11, 2025.
Nick Daicos Turns Down $5M Tasmania Devils Offer - Report on financial offers and loyalty on July 10, 2025.
Daicos puts Pies fans’ minds at ease - Confirmation of club commitment on October 11, 2025.
Daicos’ shock Pies exit revelation - Discussion of future plans and salary cap pressures on June 25, 2025.
