Carlton midfielder Elijah Hollands is the subject of widespread public concern following his visibly strained performance during the Blues' recent loss to Collingwood. Footage circulating widely shows Hollands appearing physically and emotionally distressed during the match on Thursday night. His coach, Michael Voss, acknowledged the player's significant disappointment, stating Hollands felt he had "let people down" due to his performance.
Hollands' game time was significantly curtailed, playing only 60% of the match and recording just one disposal. He spent a considerable portion of the final quarter on the bench. This limited involvement, coupled with his apparent distress, has led to intense scrutiny and worry among fans and observers about his welfare. Voss noted that Hollands was "pretty shattered with his game" and "struggled to get his way into it."
Public Reaction and Club Support
Videos circulating online after the game appeared to capture Hollands behaving in an "erratic manner," including a gesture directed at teammates and the crowd. This has prompted questions about player readiness and the club's immediate oversight during the game. Speaking on Friday morning, commentator King questioned why the club hadn't removed Hollands from the field earlier given his apparent struggles.
Read More: Alexis Ohanian buys second TGL team for women's league
Carlton has stated it will support Hollands through this period. The club emphasized a focus on the "welfare component" while acknowledging the need to offer an explanation to supporters.
Past Issues and Personal Leave
This episode brings to the forefront Hollands' prior history with personal struggles and time away from the game. In March 2025, the 22-year-old took an "indefinite leave of absence" from AFL football due to personal issues, with the club publicly supporting his decision. This followed a period where Hollands had requested help from the club "with openness."
His earlier career also saw delays, including a two-game ban for a drugs infraction. In October 2025, reports surfaced of Hollands' solitary battle with mental health challenges, amid fan speculation of excessive partying. He had previously taken a "life reset at a mental health retreat," aiming to return to AFL action. At that time, Carlton had suggested Hollands "explore his options," a move he reportedly did not contest, stating he was "not upset" but focused on maintaining his mental health. He was a Gold Coast Suns player when an incident involving cocaine found in his wallet occurred at The Star casino.
Read More: Lance Collard faces 10-week ban for homophobic slur in VFL match
Despite these past difficulties, Hollands has featured in all six games this season prior to the Collingwood match, averaging 18.4 possessions. The club has indicated it will support Hollands as he moves forward.
