Dr. Oz Looks at Maine Medicaid Money Problems

The head of CMS, Dr. Oz, is looking into how Maine spends Medicaid money. An audit found over $45 million in wrong payments. Dr. Oz is asking the state for more information on how it stops fraud.
By Newsroom | Healthcare, Maine |

Concerns over improper payments in Maine's Medicaid program have drawn the attention of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), now led by Administrator Dr. Mehmet Oz. The federal agency is emphasizing the need for stricter oversight and accountability within state-administered healthcare programs, particularly concerning allegations of fraud and waste. This federal scrutiny has led to a direct engagement with Maine's state government, signaling a broader federal effort to curb financial irregularities in Medicare and Medicaid nationwide.

Context

Reports indicate that Dr. Oz, who took on the role of CMS Administrator in April 2025, has actively begun addressing findings of potential fraud and improper spending within state-run programs. A key focus has been a recent audit of Maine's Medicaid program. This audit, released last month, identified significant issues with payments for autism services, totaling over $45 million in improper disbursements.

Read More: Many People Still Waiting Long Times for NHS Hospital Care

Maine in the Crosshairs, As CMS Administrator Dr. Oz Goes Ham on Medicare Fraud - 1

  • Timeline of Federal Involvement:

  • April 21, 2025: Dr. Mehmet Oz is sworn in as CMS Administrator. (Article 5)

  • March 14, 2025: Dr. Oz, during his confirmation hearing, pledges to crack down on fraud within Medicare Advantage and expresses a commitment to oversight. (Article 6)

  • 1 day ago: Dr. Oz addresses findings of a Maine Medicaid audit, highlighting improper payments and sending a letter to Governor Janet Mills requesting information on the state's fraud prevention measures. (Article 1)

  • 1 day ago: CMS publicly criticizes Maine's Medicaid controls, likening them to an "open cash register." (Article 2)

  • 2 days ago: The U.S. Inspector General's Office comments on the Maine Medicaid audit, noting that increased payment activity initially flagged the need for an audit and that issues with supporting documentation for autism services could impact care quality. (Article 3)

  • 1 week ago: California Governor Gavin Newsom files a civil rights complaint against Dr. Oz over his remarks regarding hospice fraud in Los Angeles. (Article 12, Article 13)

  • 2 weeks ago: CMS begins a process to withhold federal funds from Minnesota over alleged non-compliance, though specific audit results for federal losses are not cited. (Article 4)

  • 3 weeks ago: CMS Administrator Oz and other officials visit "fraud hot spots" in home health and hospice care in Nevada and California. (Article 10)

Federal Emphasis on Fraud Prevention

CMS, under Dr. Oz's leadership, is intensifying efforts to combat fraud, waste, and abuse across Medicare and Medicaid programs. This initiative appears to be part of a broader federal strategy to reform healthcare spending and improve program integrity.

Read More: Susan Collins Runs for Maine Senate Again

Maine in the Crosshairs, As CMS Administrator Dr. Oz Goes Ham on Medicare Fraud - 2

  • Dr. Oz's Stance: Dr. Oz has been vocal about his commitment to addressing these issues. He has stated that his goal is to "improve the health care of the American people" and sees cracking down on fraud as a rational approach to achieving this. (Article 7) He has also used phrases like "there is a new sheriff in town" to signal a more aggressive approach to oversight. (Article 6)

  • Broader Crackdown: The focus on Maine is not an isolated event. CMS and the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) are implementing national measures, including proposed rules that could affect hospital participation in Medicare and Medicaid. (Article 2) The agency has also visited areas identified as "fraud hot spots" for home health and hospice care. (Article 10)

  • Allegations in Other States: Similar concerns have been raised regarding other states. CMS is reportedly initiating action to withhold federal funds from Minnesota due to non-compliance, although specific federal losses are not detailed in the reports. (Article 4) Investigations into New York's Medicaid programs are also ongoing. (Article 9)

Maine's Response to Audit Findings

The audit of Maine's Medicaid program has prompted a direct response from federal officials and raised questions about the state's current safeguards against improper payments and potential fraud.

Read More: Coniston Village May Lose Doctor's Office as No New Doctors Apply

Maine in the Crosshairs, As CMS Administrator Dr. Oz Goes Ham on Medicare Fraud - 3

  • Audit Results: The audit uncovered that Maine made over $45 million in improper payments for autism services. While investigators noted that these payments appeared to be more the result of errors than intentional fraud, federal officials are using such instances as evidence for a necessary federal crackdown. (Article 1)

  • Inspector General's Input: An Assistant Regional Inspector General for Audit Services noted that an increase in payments initially alerted the Inspector General's Office to conduct the audit. The office identified deficiencies in supporting documentation for certain sessions, such as incomplete session notes regarding services provided or goals addressed. These issues, according to the Inspector General, could significantly affect the quality of care for children with autism. (Article 3)

  • Federal Communication: Dr. Oz has sent a letter to Maine Governor Janet Mills demanding more information on how the state is preventing fraud. (Article 1) CMS has publicly stated that Maine "needs to clean up its act," framing the issue as a moral concern and advocating for the use of tax enforcement to address fraudulent providers. (Article 2)

  • State Controls: Federal officials have characterized Maine's Medicaid controls as weak, metaphorically likening the situation to leaving a "cash register wide open." (Article 2)

The actions by CMS and its administrator have also led to friction with state officials and ignited political discourse, particularly concerning accusations of discrimination and broad federal overreach.

Read More: Senator Susan Collins Says She Will Run Again for Senate Seat in Maine

Maine in the Crosshairs, As CMS Administrator Dr. Oz Goes Ham on Medicare Fraud - 4

  • Governor Mills: Dr. Oz's letter to Governor Mills signifies a direct federal challenge to the state's administration of its Medicaid program. (Article 1)

  • Governor Newsom's Complaint: California Governor Gavin Newsom has filed a civil rights complaint against Dr. Oz. The complaint stems from a video Oz posted alleging hospice fraud in Los Angeles, which Newsom's office claims discriminated against the city's Armenian community. The video highlighted a concentrated number of hospices in a specific area, suggesting potential widespread fraud. (Article 12, Article 13) Details of the alleged fraud have not been fully disclosed by Oz's office. (Article 12)

  • Political Context: The emphasis on fraud by the CMS administrator occurs within a broader political landscape where Republican leaders have stated intentions to target fraud, waste, and abuse in government healthcare programs rather than cutting funding to programs like Medicare and Medicaid. (Article 5) Dr. Oz's past statements and business dealings, including owning stock in a major Medicare Advantage insurer, have also drawn attention. (Article 8) He has, however, stated he would divest certain holdings if confirmed. (Article 8)

Expert Analysis

The intensified federal scrutiny on state Medicaid programs, particularly under the current CMS administration, highlights a persistent challenge in managing healthcare finances and ensuring program integrity.

Read More: Senator Moreno Talks About Healthcare Costs and Immigration

"The primary responsibility for preventing and detecting fraud against Medicaid lies with state Medicaid agencies." (Article 4)

  • Pei Sun, Assistant Regional Inspector General for Audit Services (HHS-OIG): Emphasized that an increase in payments prompted the audit and that issues with documentation for autism services were found, potentially impacting care quality. (Article 3)

  • Dr. Mehmet Oz, CMS Administrator: States his goal is to "improve the health care of the American people" and views combating fraud as a rational strategy. (Article 7) He has also used strong rhetoric, stating, "Part of this is just recognizing there is a new sheriff in town." (Article 6)

Conclusion

The recent actions by CMS Administrator Dr. Mehmet Oz underscore a clear federal directive to increase oversight and enforcement regarding alleged fraud and improper payments within state-administered Medicare and Medicaid programs. The situation in Maine, involving over $45 million in improper payments for autism services, has become a focal point, leading to direct communication between CMS and Governor Janet Mills' administration. While the audit's findings in Maine pointed towards errors rather than deliberate fraud, federal officials are leveraging these cases as justification for a nationwide "crackdown."

Read More: Autistic Man Dies of Starvation After Hospital Failures

This approach has generated significant attention, including criticism and legal challenges from state leaders, such as California Governor Gavin Newsom, who has accused Dr. Oz of discrimination in his pursuit of alleged hospice fraud. The broader context involves a stated federal commitment to targeting fraud, waste, and abuse within healthcare programs. The effectiveness of these intensified enforcement efforts and their impact on state-federal relations remain under observation.

Sources Used

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What did the audit in Maine find?
The audit found that Maine made over $45 million in wrong payments for autism services.
Q: Who is Dr. Oz?
Dr. Oz is the head of CMS, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.
Q: What is CMS doing about this?
CMS is asking Maine for more information on how it stops fraud and is pushing for better oversight of state Medicaid programs.
Q: Is this happening in other states?
Yes, CMS is also looking at other states and taking steps to prevent fraud and waste in Medicare and Medicaid programs across the country.