The tension between Assam's Chief Minister and leaders of the Congress party has moved from public platforms to the courtroom. A Guwahati court has issued an order to prevent specific Congress figures from making further statements deemed defamatory against Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma. This action follows a substantial legal claim filed by the Chief Minister, signaling a sharp escalation in their ongoing political dispute.
The Legal Restraint
A court in Guwahati has ordered Gaurav Gogoi, Bhupesh Baghel, and Jitendra Singh, all prominent Congress leaders, to stop making any public statements that could be considered defamatory towards Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma. This order, known as an ad-interim injunction, was issued by Nayanjyoti Sarma, the Civil Judge of Senior Division No. 1. The court stated that failing to issue this order would defeat justice and could lead to multiple legal cases. The injunction also applies to a local Assamese daily newspaper. The defendants are required to appear in court on March 9 for the next hearing.
Read More: MDMK Wants More Seats to Get Official Recognition
Roots of the Legal Action
The court's decision stems from a defamation case filed by Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma against the Congress leaders. He is seeking ₹500 crore in damages. The Chief Minister alleges that the Congress leaders made false and malicious statements against him during a press conference held on February 4.
These statements were made in the context of the Congress party raising allegations concerning illegal land ownership and corruption in various government departments. The party also launched a website, whoishbs.com, to present information they claim is related to the Chief Minister's assets and land holdings.
The Congress leaders, in turn, have questioned the timing of Sarma's recent comments linking Gaurav Gogoi to Pakistan. They have also pointed to an AI-generated video that allegedly depicted the Chief Minister in a negative light.
Key Players and Their Claims
| Figure | Role/Affiliation | Allegations Made Against Them / Action Taken | Claims Made Against Others / Actions Taken |
|---|---|---|---|
| Himanta Biswa Sarma | Chief Minister of Assam | Accused by Congress of illegal land ownership, corruption, and amassing assets. | Filed a ₹500 crore defamation suit seeking damages for alleged false, malicious, and defamatory statements. |
| Gaurav Gogoi | Assam Congress President, MP | Named in the defamation suit. Alleged by Sarma to have made defamatory statements. | Accused Sarma's family of grabbing approximately 12,000 bighas of land. Questioned the timing of Sarma's comments linking him to Pakistan. |
| Bhupesh Baghel | Former Chhattisgarh CM, Congress Leader | Named in the defamation suit. Alleged by Sarma to have made defamatory statements. | Echoed criticism against Sarma. |
| Jitendra Singh | Congress Leader | Named in the defamation suit. Alleged by Sarma to have made defamatory statements. | No specific claims attributed in provided text. |
| Debabrata Saikia | Congress Legislature Party Leader | Named by Sarma for potential defamation proceedings. | No specific claims attributed in provided text. |
| Assamese Daily | Local Newspaper | Included in the court's restraint order for publishing potentially defamatory material. | No specific actions attributed. |
Circumstantial Evidence and Questions
Were the statements made by Gaurav Gogoi, Bhupesh Baghel, and Jitendra Singh at the February 4 press conference the specific statements that formed the basis of the defamation case?
Did the launch of the website whoishbs.com by the Congress party precede or coincide with the statements that led to the lawsuit?
Is there a connection between the Congress's allegations of land grabbing and the Chief Minister's counter-claim of defamation, beyond the immediate press conference?
What is the exact nature of the allegations that triggered the ₹500 crore suit, as Sarma did not spell them out in detail initially?
Court's Ad-Interim Injunction
The court's order on Wednesday imposes an ad-interim injunction until the defendants appear in court. This means:
Read More: Supreme Court Gives New Rules for Forest Evictions in Assam
Gogoi, Baghel, and Singh are restrained from making, publishing, circulating, or disseminating any further defamatory statements or materials concerning the petitioner (Himanta Biswa Sarma).
The order extends to a prominent Assamese daily.
The court found that without this order, justice would be defeated, and there was a high possibility of multiple lawsuits.
Political Ramifications and Context
This legal battle is unfolding amidst a politically charged environment in Assam. The timing of the defamation case and the court's restraint order are significant, especially with heightened political activity in the state. The Congress has accused the Chief Minister's family of acquiring a substantial amount of land, claims that Sarma has vehemently denied.
Simultaneously, Congress MLAs filed a police complaint regarding an AI-generated video allegedly showing the Chief Minister. Sarma has stated he will pursue legal remedies to protect his reputation, emphasizing the need for accountability when serious allegations are made without proof. The political contest, it appears, is now being fought in both public forums and legal arenas.
Read More: Gen Z's Big Test: Can Young Voters Change Bangladesh?
Expert Observations
Legal analysts note that such injunctions are typically granted when there is a clear indication that continued statements could cause irreparable harm to reputation. The court's assessment of potential multiplicity of proceedings suggests it views the alleged defamation as an ongoing issue. The burden of proof will eventually lie with the Chief Minister to demonstrate that the statements were indeed false, malicious, and caused significant harm to his reputation, warranting the requested damages.
Conclusion and Next Steps
The Guwahati court has temporarily barred key Congress leaders from making statements against Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma in response to a ₹500 crore defamation suit. This judicial intervention marks a significant development in the escalating political conflict between the Chief Minister and the opposition party. The core allegations revolve around claims of land acquisition and corruption made by the Congress, and the Chief Minister's assertion that these are false and damaging.
Read More: Minister Asks to Stop Firing Top Civil Servant While New Papers Come Out
The next critical juncture will be the court appearance scheduled for March 9, when the defendants are expected to present their response. The outcome of this hearing will determine the further course of the injunction and the defamation proceedings, potentially setting a precedent for how political disputes involving allegations of impropriety are handled legally in the state. The broader political landscape will also be watching to see how this legal challenge impacts campaign narratives and public discourse.
Sources:
New Indian Express: Guwahati court restrains Congress leaders from making 'defamatory' statements against Assam CM
The Sentinel Assam: Guwahati court bars Congress leaders from remarks against Assam CM in Rs 500 crore defamation case
Prokerala: Assam CM defamation case: Court asks Gaurav Gogoi and others to appear before it on March 9
The Sentinel Assam: Assam CM Moves Court, Seeks Rs 500 Crore Damages in Defamation Case Against Congress Leaders
News9 Live: Assam CM files Rs 500 crore suit against Congress leaders: Poll ground shifts from campaigns to courtrooms
Rediff: Assam CM Sarma files Rs 500 cr defamation case against Congress leaders
Economic Times: Assam CM Himanta files ₹500 cr defamation case against Congress leaders Gaurav Gogoi, Jitendra Singh, Bhupesh Baghel
Assam Tribune: Assam CM files Rs 500-cr defamation case against Congress leaders over asset claims
The Hindu: Assam CM Himanta files ₹500-crore defamation suit against Gaurav Gogoi, others
Devdiscourse: Assam CM Files Massive Defamation Suit Against Congress Leaders | Politics
Hindustan Times: Sarma files defamation case, seeks ₹500 crore in damages from Congress leaders
Scroll.in: Assam: Himanta Sarma files defamation suit against Gaurav Gogoi, Congress leaders
ETV Bharat: Assam CM Sarma Files Rs 500 Crore Defamation Suit Against Congress Leaders For 'Malicious Charges'
Read More: Nikki Haley Says Many People Don't Feel Hopeful About the Economy
