Bogotá Ajiaco Soup Recipe Debate 2024: Why 3 Potato Types Are Needed for Authenticity

Traditional Ajiaco uses 3 types of potatoes to get the right thickness. This is different from normal chicken soup which usually only uses 1 type of potato.
By Newsroom | Food, Bogotá |

Bogotá's signature soup, Ajiaco Bogotano, a purportedly comforting chicken and potato concoction, finds itself at the center of a culinary identity crisis. Disagreements over its essential components, particularly the varieties of potatoes, are a stark reminder of the fluid, contested nature of tradition.

The heart of the matter lies in the potatoes. Sources diverge significantly on the type and quantity of tubers required. Some insist on papas criollas, the small, yellow, buttery Colombian potatoes, hailing them as the "best." Others offer Yukon Gold as a substitute, a choice met with less certainty. Further complicating the narrative, recipes liberally mix russet potatoes alongside Yukon Golds, or suggest diced yucca as an alternative, muddying the waters of what constitutes an authentic preparation.

Beyond the potato quandary, the soup's identity is further fractured by debates surrounding other ingredients. The inclusion of guascas, a particular herb, is deemed essential by some, yet absent from certain recipe variations. Toppings themselves are a battlefield, with suggestions ranging from chicken and corn to cream, capers, and avocado, each adding a distinct layer of interpretation to the dish.

Read More: Grace Young Tai Shan Chicken Recipe for Panda Debut on March 11 Makes Cooking Easy

The very definition of Ajiaco Bogotano appears to be a construct, an evolving narrative rather than a fixed truth. While ostensibly a simple soup, its preparation reveals a complex interplay of ingredient preferences, regional interpretations, and the inherent difficulty in pinning down a definitive culinary artifact.

Isles land Blues captain Schenn for playoff push - 1

A Labyrinth of Spuds and Stock

The foundation of Ajiaco Bogotano, the broth, also presents a range of approaches. While many recipes call for chicken stock, the quality and flavor profile vary. Suggestions for "high-quality" stock, even specific brands, emerge, hinting at an attempt to imbue the dish with a specific depth of flavor. However, simpler versions start with basic water and chicken bouillon, presenting a less refined, though perhaps more accessible, starting point.

Read More: Smothered Skirt Steak Recipes Change in May 2025 for Easy Dinners

The process of building the soup also exhibits a lack of consensus. Some advocate for a layering approach, adding diced potatoes, yucca, and corn to the simmering chicken. Others describe browning the chicken first, then adding it to the main pot. The assembly of aromatic elements, like onions, garlic, and cilantro, also shows divergence, with some opting for a cheesecloth pouch and others a more direct addition to the pot.

Origins and Interpretations

Ajiaco Bogotano is presented as a dish deeply rooted in Colombian tradition, specifically from Bogotá. The mention of potatoes originating from the Andes grounds the soup in a historical context, yet the very diversity of potato choices suggests a departure from a singular, ancient lineage.

The proliferation of Ajiaco recipes across various online platforms, each with its own subtle variations and suggested substitutions, underscores the democratizing, and perhaps diluting, effect of modern food media. What was once perhaps a more codified family or regional recipe is now a dispersed, adaptable entity, subject to the whims of individual cooks and available ingredients. The quest for a singular "authentic" Ajiaco may be an exercise in futility, a postmodern symptom of our fractured, eclectic culinary landscape.

Read More: How to cook couscous: easy 15-minute recipe for fluffy grain

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Why do people in Bogotá disagree about the Ajiaco soup recipe in 2024?
People disagree because some use only one potato, but tradition says you need three specific types: Sabanera, Pastusa, and Criolla. Using the wrong potatoes changes the soup's thickness and the traditional taste that families expect.
Q: What are the three specific potatoes needed for authentic Ajiaco Bogotano?
The recipe needs Papa Sabanera for texture, Papa Pastusa to thicken the broth, and small yellow Papa Criolla to give the soup its color. If a cook uses Yukon Gold or Russet potatoes instead, the soup will not have the correct creamy feel.
Q: Why is the guascas herb so important for Bogotá chicken soup?
Guascas is a special herb that gives Ajiaco its unique smell and grassy flavor. Without this specific herb, the dish is just a regular chicken soup instead of a traditional meal from the Andes mountains.
Q: What toppings must be served with Ajiaco in Bogotá restaurants?
A traditional bowl is served with heavy cream, salty capers, a slice of avocado, and a piece of corn. These four toppings are added at the table to help balance the heavy potato flavor of the soup.