Anas Sarwar, the leader of Scottish Labour, has publicly called for Keir Starmer to resign as Prime Minister. This intervention comes at a critical juncture, potentially creating a significant leadership challenge within the Labour party. Sarwar stated that his primary loyalty is to Scotland and that he believes Starmer's premiership has been marked by too many mistakes.
The call for resignation was made at an emergency press conference on Monday afternoon. Sarwar indicated that the ongoing "distraction needs to end." He expressed that while he and Starmer had campaigned together, and that his decision was not easy, he felt compelled to act. Sarwar did not name a successor, stating he was not backing any particular candidate to replace Starmer.
Timeline of Events
Recent Past: Keir Starmer and Anas Sarwar had previously worked together with the aim of returning Labour to power in both London and Edinburgh.
Within the last 24 hours: Reports indicate that Keir Starmer's chief of staff, Morgan McSweeney, resigned due to his role in appointing Peter Mandelson as ambassador to the United States.
Monday Afternoon: Anas Sarwar holds an emergency press conference and calls for Keir Starmer to resign as Prime Minister.
Following Sarwar's Statement: A number of Cabinet ministers have publicly expressed their support for Keir Starmer on social media, urging him to "stay the course."
Evidence Presented
Statement by Anas Sarwar: Sarwar declared that he believes Keir Starmer should step down. He framed his loyalty as being to Scotland and cited "too many mistakes" during Starmer's tenure.
Cabinet Minister Responses:
Foreign Secretary Yvette Cooper stated, "We need to stay the course and deliver the change this country voted for.”
Chancellor Rachel Reeves also gave her backing to Keir Starmer, with at least eight Cabinet ministers reportedly rallying behind him.
Political Context: Sarwar's intervention occurs shortly before Keir Starmer is scheduled to address Labour MPs at a Parliamentary Labour Party meeting. It also precedes the upcoming Holyrood elections in May, where current opinion polls suggest the SNP is likely to be re-elected, with Labour contending for second place. Sarwar suggested that continuing on the current path could lead to a third decade of SNP rule in Scotland.
Sarwar's Motivation: Loyalty to Scotland
Anas Sarwar's public call for Keir Starmer's resignation appears rooted in his perception of what is best for Scotland. He stated, "But he says his first loyalty is to Scotland." This suggests a belief that the current leadership or direction under Starmer is detrimental to Labour's prospects and governance in Scotland.
Read More: Minister Asks to Stop New Top Job Choice Until Old Files Are Out
Election Concerns: Sarwar voiced concerns that the current course could result in a "third decade of SNP rule in Holyrood." This indicates a strategic calculation that distancing himself and Scottish Labour from the national leadership may be necessary for electoral survival.
Personal Relationship vs. Political Necessity: The articles suggest a prior working relationship between Sarwar and Starmer, with both aiming for a return to power. Sarwar's statement acknowledges this, noting they "have campaigned together," but implies that political realities have superseded this past cooperation.
The Mandelson Appointment Controversy
The appointment of Peter Mandelson as ambassador to the United States has been cited as a significant factor contributing to the current crisis. Morgan McSweeney, Starmer's chief of staff, resigned over his role in this decision. While Sarwar's call for resignation predates this specific event, it occurred in close proximity, amplifying the pressure on Starmer. Sarwar also explicitly condemned the decision to appoint Peter Mandelson, linking it to the broader issues he perceives with Starmer's leadership.
Read More: Scotland Faces Snow and Ice Warning
The Wider Labour Response
Following Anas Sarwar's public statement, there has been a notable reaction from Cabinet ministers. Many have taken to social media to publicly reaffirm their support for Keir Starmer.
Public Demonstrations of Support: The intervention from Sarwar, a senior figure within the Labour party, has prompted a stream of ministers to publicly defend Starmer. This suggests a party effort to contain the damage and present a united front.
Questions of Unity: The extent to which other senior Labour figures will publicly back Starmer remains a key question. The coming hours and days will likely reveal the full spectrum of support and dissent within the party.
Conclusion and Implications
Anas Sarwar's demand for Keir Starmer to resign represents a significant challenge to Starmer's leadership. The timing, just before a significant party meeting and with elections looming in Scotland, suggests a strategic move by Sarwar to either salvage Scottish Labour's electoral prospects or to signal a broader dissatisfaction within the party.
Read More: Minister and Mayor Disagree with Businessman on Immigration
The swift and public response from several Cabinet ministers indicates an attempt to shore up Starmer's position. However, the depth of Sarwar's conviction and the potential for other senior figures to echo his concerns will determine the long-term impact of this event on Starmer's premiership. The situation remains fluid, with the focus now shifting to how Keir Starmer and the wider Labour party will navigate this public dissent.
Sources
BBC News: Scottish Labour leader calls for Keir Starmer to step down, saying the 'distraction needs to end'
Context: This article provides initial reporting on Sarwar's call and the subsequent reaction from Cabinet ministers.
The Guardian: Cabinet ministers rally behind Starmer after Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar calls for him to resign – UK politics live
Context: This article details Sarwar's reasoning and the Cabinet's immediate response.
New Statesman: Anas Sarwar calls for Keir Starmer to resign
Context: This report elaborates on Sarwar's statement, including his refusal to name a successor and his concerns about SNP rule.
Daily Record: Anas Sarwar calls for Keir Starmer to resign LIVE as leadership crisis deepens
Context: This live update provides context on Sarwar's political situation and the potential implications of his decision.
Evening Standard: Huge blow to Stamer as Scottish Labour leader tells him to quit - live updates
Context: This article highlights the support from Cabinet ministers Yvette Cooper and Rachel Reeves.
Sky News: Scottish Labour leader calls for Starmer to stand down
Context: This report places Sarwar's intervention in the context of McSweeney's resignation and the upcoming Holyrood elections.
Huffington Post: Hammer Blow For Keir Starmer As Scottish Labour Leader Anas Sarwar Calls On Him To Quit
Context: This article emphasizes the "hammer blow" nature of Sarwar's demand and his efforts to prevent electoral "annihilation."
The Independent: Starmer latest: PM must resign, Scottish Labour leader says as pressure piles on
Context: This article reports on Sarwar's call for resignation amid mounting pressure on Starmer.
Read More: Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain Scores Winning Goal on Celtic Debut
