Pippa Middleton and her husband, James Matthews, are facing local backlash in their West Berkshire village over their decision to close a popular footpath that has historically provided public access. Residents describe the couple as "inconsiderate," "snooty," and feeling they are "better than everyone else," with some calling the situation "extremely dangerous." The couple purchased Barton Court, a sprawling estate, several years ago and subsequently installed gates and signage, declaring the road private and cutting off access to Mill Lane, a route long used by villagers to connect surrounding areas.
Locals claim Middleton and Matthews have adopted a "snooty approach to village life" and are "not very popular." This sentiment appears to stem from the closure of Mill Lane, a pathway described by one resident, Victoria Livesey, as one "they were part of village life and never discouraged villagers from using Mill Lane." She notes she has used the route for nearly 50 years. The dispute centers on the couple's perceived sense of entitlement, with some villagers stating, "They think they can decide who can walk where and when."
Further fueling local discontent were noise complaints and disruptions associated with a recent 50th birthday party thrown by Middleton for Matthews. Neighbors described the event, which featured a Spitfire flyover and music played until the early hours of the morning, as "inconsiderate" and "wild," with one neighbor expressing concern for pets. Prince William and Kate Middleton reportedly attended this event, which also drew criticism for its scale and perceived lack of consideration for the surrounding community.
A Pattern of Discontent
This is not the first time Middleton and Matthews have drawn criticism from their neighbors. Following their purchase of the estate, the couple implemented the footpath closure. Some residents acknowledge the couple's desire for privacy while raising their three young children but question the method, stating it should not come "at the expense of the community." A government-appointed planning inspector is set to review the couple's rights to withdraw long-standing access to the track.
The narrative of "diva behavior" has surfaced previously, with one report detailing past incidents that elicited eye-rolls, though it also suggests moments of kindness. The media's portrayal and coverage of Middleton have also been debated, with some questioning if it is "inappropriate." The contrast between their wealth and their interactions with the local community appears to be a significant point of friction.
Background on the Estate and Couple
Pippa Middleton, sister to Catherine, Princess of Wales, and James Matthews, a billionaire hedge fund manager and heir to a Scottish lairdship, reside at Barton Court, a 32-room mansion situated on a 145-acre estate. The couple purchased the Grade I-listed property several years ago. Matthews is also noted for his family's title, with Middleton potentially becoming Lady Glen Affric.
Reports suggest the couple has also been involved in other ventures, including a farm named Bucklebury Farm, which included a gift shop and plans for expansion. The couple's wealth and perceived disconnect from local village life seem central to the ongoing tensions. Some past commentary has touched upon the Middletons' background, suggesting they have faced criticism for their ambition and social mobility.