Doctor Says Epstein Death Not Suicide After New Files Released

A doctor who studies bodies is questioning the official reason for Jeffrey Epstein's death. He says new government papers show signs that he might have been killed, not that he killed himself. This makes people ask more questions about how he died in jail.
By Newsroom | Crime, United States |

A prominent forensic pathologist has once again questioned the official finding that Jeffrey Epstein died by suicide in federal prison. This renewed challenge comes following the release of millions of pages of documents by the Department of Justice (DOJ). The pathologist, Dr. Michael Baden, asserts that evidence points away from suicide and suggests foul play may have occurred. This development adds further pressure on the DOJ as lawmakers continue to release unredacted information from the files, fueling public interest and debate surrounding the circumstances of Epstein's death.

Jeffrey Epstein's 'suicide' under fire: Pathologist renews homicide charge after 3 million page DOJ leak - 1

Context of Jeffrey Epstein's Death and Subsequent Investigations

Jeffrey Epstein, a financier accused of sex trafficking, was found dead in his jail cell at the Metropolitan Correctional Center in New York on August 10, 2019. The New York City Medical Examiner's office ruled his death a suicide by hanging. However, this conclusion has faced persistent skepticism.

Read More: Lawmaker's Epstein List Faces Questions About Truth

Jeffrey Epstein's 'suicide' under fire: Pathologist renews homicide charge after 3 million page DOJ leak - 2

  • Initial Suspicion: Soon after his death, the official account was met with doubt. Attorney General William Barr acknowledged a "perfect storm of screw-ups" within the Bureau of Prisons, noting negligence and failures in job performance related to Epstein's incarceration.

  • DOJ Investigations and Document Releases: The DOJ and FBI have conducted reviews into Epstein's case. In July 2025, they released findings stating there was no evidence of a "client list" or that Epstein blackmailed prominent individuals. They reiterated their conclusion that Epstein died by suicide and that no one else in his orbit would face charges beyond those already convicted, like Ghislaine Maxwell. This release of approximately 3 million pages of documents aimed to debunk conspiracy theories.

  • Contradictory Statements and Public Skepticism: Despite official pronouncements, public skepticism has endured. Ghislaine Maxwell, in a jailhouse interview released in August 2025, stated she did not believe Epstein died by suicide. Similarly, Mark Epstein, Jeffrey Epstein's brother, has publicly questioned the official narrative, pointing to the pooling of blood in his brother's body as suspicious and suggesting he may have died hours before being found.

  • Lawmaker Actions: Lawmakers, such as Ro Khanna, have been involved in releasing unredacted names from the DOJ files, keeping the public discourse active.

Evidence and Expert Perspectives

The debate surrounding Jeffrey Epstein's death centers on forensic evidence and official findings, often presenting conflicting interpretations.

Read More: New Clues in Nancy Guthrie Disappearance Case

Jeffrey Epstein's 'suicide' under fire: Pathologist renews homicide charge after 3 million page DOJ leak - 3

  • Forensic Pathologist's Claims:

  • Dr. Michael Baden, a renowned forensic pathologist, has consistently challenged the suicide ruling.

  • He points to multiple fractures in Epstein's hyoid bone and thyroid cartilage, stating that while single hyoid fractures can occur in hangings, multiple fractures are statistically more indicative of manual strangulation.

  • Baden's initial examination, as reported, noted that the medical examiner at the time also initially sought more information.

  • Official Findings:

  • The New York City Medical Examiner's office officially ruled Epstein's death a suicide by hanging.

  • The DOJ and FBI, in their July 2025 findings, concluded Epstein died by suicide and found no evidence to support claims of murder or blackmail. They stated that a review of Epstein materials found no indication he was murdered while in custody.

  • Conflicting Interpretations of Physical Evidence:

  • Mark Epstein noted the positioning of lividity (blood pooling) in his brother's body, suggesting it was inconsistent with a hanging position if he had died hours earlier, as he claims.

  • Reports from the time indicated discrepancies were noted between a jailhouse photo and Epstein's ear, which Snopes later debunked, attributing the differences to aging of the photo.

  • Ghislaine Maxwell's Statement:

  • Maxwell stated to federal prosecutors, "life is cheap in prison," and expressed her disbelief in Epstein's suicide. She did not offer speculation on who might have been responsible for his death.

The "Client List" Controversy

A significant point of contention has been the existence and nature of an alleged "client list" belonging to Epstein, which some officials had previously alluded to.

Read More: Police Patrol Hackney Streets After Social Media Call for School Fight

Jeffrey Epstein's 'suicide' under fire: Pathologist renews homicide charge after 3 million page DOJ leak - 4

  • Initial Allusions: In February 2025, former Attorney General Pam Bondi stated on Fox News that a client list was "sitting on my desk right now to review." This statement fueled theories about a broader conspiracy.

  • DOJ Clarification: In July 2025, the DOJ clarified that there was no specific "client list" in the way it was understood. Spokespersons indicated that Bondi's reference likely encompassed the entirety of all the paperwork related to the Epstein investigation, such as flight logs, rather than a discrete document detailing clients.

  • Debunking Conspiracy Theories: The DOJ and FBI's released findings explicitly stated that Epstein did not have a "client list" and that their review implicated no one else in his orbit beyond those already charged.

  • Lingering Questions: Some, like activist Jack Posobiec, have questioned why Ghislaine Maxwell remains in jail if there were no clients involved in Epstein's operations.

Allegations of Procedural Failures and Negligence

Beyond the cause of death, serious allegations of procedural failures within the Bureau of Prisons have been raised, contributing to the climate of suspicion.

Read More: US Government Looks Closer at Citizenship and Voting

  • Negligence and Misconduct: A DOJ Inspector General's report released in June 2023 castigated jail officials for repeated "negligence, misconduct, and outright job performance failures" concerning Epstein's incarceration and death.

  • Warden and Guard Actions: Following Epstein's death, the warden of the Metropolitan Correctional Center, L t gen., was removed from duty, and two staff members assigned to Epstein's unit were placed on administrative leave. Later, two guards on duty were indicted, though they received community service as a penalty.

  • Initial Injuries: Judge Richard Berman, who was overseeing Epstein's criminal case, inquired about the lack of a definitive explanation regarding Epstein's prior injuries sustained on July 23, 2019, prior to his death.

Renewed Scrutiny Amidst Document Release

The recent release of millions of pages of DOJ documents has not quelled doubts but has instead provided new impetus for re-examining the circumstances of Epstein's death.

Read More: Father Remembers 12-Year-Old Daughter Lost in Tumbler Ridge Shooting

  • Dr. Baden's Formal Challenge: The latest development sees Dr. Michael Baden formally renewing his challenge to the official ruling. This action is framed as a response to the newly available, extensive documentation.

  • Continued Public Pressure: Lawmakers continue to push for transparency, with releases of unredacted names from the files. This ongoing flow of information keeps the case in the public eye and encourages further investigation.

  • Official Stance Unchanged: The DOJ maintains its stance that Epstein died by suicide and has stated it does not plan to release any further documents related to the matter.

Conclusion and Implications

The official determination of Jeffrey Epstein's death as a suicide by hanging continues to face significant challenges from forensic experts and remains a subject of intense public scrutiny. The recent release of extensive DOJ documentation, while intended to debunk conspiracy theories, has instead provided a new focal point for renewed questioning, particularly from Dr. Michael Baden. His assertion of multiple hyoid fractures as indicative of manual strangulation contrasts with the official ruling.

Read More: New Papers Show Idaho Killer May Have Moved Victims' Bodies

The controversy surrounding the alleged "client list" has been addressed by the DOJ as a misunderstanding of terminology, but this clarification has not entirely erased public skepticism. Simultaneously, documented findings of widespread negligence and misconduct within the Bureau of Prisons in the handling of Epstein's incarceration and death lend credence to the idea that systemic failures may have contributed to the events leading to his demise.

Despite the DOJ's reaffirmation of the suicide ruling and its intention to cease further document releases, the persistence of expert challenges, the ongoing interest from lawmakers and the public, and the historical context of procedural failures suggest that the definitive account of Jeffrey Epstein's death may still be contested.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is the main news about Jeffrey Epstein's death?
A doctor who studies bodies says new government papers suggest Jeffrey Epstein did not kill himself in jail. He thinks someone else might have been involved.
Q: Why is the doctor saying this now?
The U.S. government recently released many documents about the case. The doctor looked at these new papers and his old findings.
Q: What did the government say before?
The government's official reason for Epstein's death was suicide by hanging. They said they found no proof of murder.
Q: What does the doctor see as proof?
The doctor points to breaks in bones in Epstein's neck. He says these breaks can happen if someone strangles another person, not just in a hanging.