Lingering Comments and Clarifications
Chief Justice of India Surya Kant remarked that some unemployed young people, unable to find professional footing, behave akin to "cockroaches" by becoming media, social media, or RTI activists and subsequently attacking the system. This statement emerged during a Supreme Court hearing where a lawyer was being admonished for aggressively pursuing senior advocate designation. The bench, including CJI Kant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi, questioned the lawyer's conduct, suggesting such aggressive pursuit was unbecoming of someone seeking the esteemed position. The court also voiced concerns about a rising number of advocates potentially holding suspect law degrees.
The lawyer in question eventually apologized and was permitted to withdraw their petition. The CJI reportedly stated that if the Delhi High Court were to grant senior advocate status to the petitioner, the Supreme Court would overturn the decision based on his professional demeanor. The court emphasized that senior advocate designation is a conferred honor, not a status to be aggressively sought.
Read More: Blanche Recusal Order Affects Justice Dept. Work
In a subsequent clarification, CJI Surya Kant described any suggestion that he had criticized the nation's youth as "totally baseless." He expressed pride in the country's young population, viewing them as foundational to a developed India.
Context of the Remark
The contentious remark about "cockroaches" arose when the bench was discussing the aggressive pursuit of senior advocate status by a lawyer. The CJI characterized this behavior as inappropriate, noting that some unemployed individuals might resort to activism as a means to "attack everyone." The discussion also touched upon the existence of "parasites" in society who target the system, with the CJI questioning the lawyer's alignment with such elements.
Background on Senior Advocate Designation
The designation of a lawyer as a 'Senior Advocate' in India is a prestigious honor granted by the higher courts to legal practitioners of eminence. It is not a position to be actively applied for or pursued with aggressive tactics, but rather a recognition of an individual's standing and contribution to the legal profession. The recent proceedings highlighted concerns about lawyers potentially misusing the system to attain this designation, alongside broader worries about the authenticity of legal qualifications among some practitioners.
Read More: AMMA Internal Fight: Harassment Claims Lead to Resignations
